Smt Prathima vs Chennamma on 9 March, 2026

    0
    40
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Karnataka High Court

    Smt Prathima vs Chennamma on 9 March, 2026

                                             -1-
                                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
                   HC-KAR
    
    
    
                       IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
                            DATED THIS THE 9TH DAY OF MARCH, 2026
                                          PRESENT
                         THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
                                            AND
                        THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL
                         REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.1968/2024 (PAR)
    
    
                  BETWEEN:
    
                     SMT. PRATHIMA
                     D/O SADASHIVA
                     AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
                     3-243-2, ANUGRAHA HOUSE
                     KUBALA GUDDE, HALEANGADY
    Digitally signed MANGALURU - 574146, D.K.
    by RUPA V
    Location: HIGH                                             ...APPELLANT
    COURT OF
    KARNATAKA        (BY SRI. RODDA VEERSHETTY, ADV., FOR
                         SRI. PATGAR NARENDRA HANUMANT, ADV.,)
    
                  AND:
    
                         CHENNAMMA
                         ALIAS PARVATHI (SINCE DEAD)
                         D/O BALE ALIAS PONNAPPA
                         R/AT. BHANDARA HOUSE
                         BEJAI, MANGALORE - 575 004.
    
                  1.     GIRIJA ALIAS SUGUNA
                         AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
                         D/O CHENNAMMA ALIAS PARVATHI
                         R/AT. NEAR THIMMAPPA COMPOUND
                         FALNIR, MANGALORE - 575 001.
    
                  2.     VASANTHI
                         D/O CHENNAMMA ALIAS PARVATHI
                                 -2-
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
         R/AT. BEHIND URVA MARKET
         MANGALORE - 575 006.
    
    3.   SHOBA RAVI
         AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS
         D/O VASANTHI
         R/AT. SAVITHRI NIVAS
         OLD KENT ROAD
         PANDESHWARA
         MANGALORE - 575 001.
    
    4.   KAUSHIK
         AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
         S/O SHOBA RAVI
         D/O VASANTHI
         R/AT SAVTHRI NIVAS
         OLD KENT ROAD, PANDESHWARA
         MANGALORE - 575 001.
    
    5.   ABHISHEK
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         S/O VASANTHI
         R/AT SAVTHRI NIVAS
         OLD KENT ROAD, PANDESHWARA
         MANGALORE - 575 001.
    
    6.   NALINAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O VASANTHI
         R/AT BEHIND URVA MARKET
         MANGALORE - 575 006, D.K.
    
    7.   SURESH
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         S/O VASANTHI
         R/AT BEHIND URVA MARKET
         MANGALORE - 575 006, D.K.
    
    8.   SUCHETHA ALIAS SULOCHANA
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
                                -3-
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
          D/O VASANTHI
          R/AT BEHIND URVA MARKET
          MANGALORE - 575 006, D.K.
    
    9.    NAYANA
          AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
          D/O VASANTHI
          R/AT BEHIND URVA MARKET
          MANGALORE - 575 006, D.K.
    
    10.   MAMATHA
          AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
          D/O VASANTHI
          R/AT BEHIND URVA MARKET
          MANGALORE - 575 006, D.K.
    
    11.   RAVINDRA
          S/O CHENNAMMA ALIAS PARVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 82 YEARS
          R/AT N.I.G. 21
          HOUSING BOARD COLONY
          KAVOOR, MANGALORE - 575 006, D.K.
    
    12.   SHILAMANI
          D/O LATE CHENNAMMA ALIAS PARVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS
          R/AT BHANDARA HOUSE
          BEJAI, MANGALORE - 575 004 D.K.
    
    13.   SOWMYA
          AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
          D/O SHILAMANI
          R/AT. BHANDARA HOUSE
          BEJAI, MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
    
    14.   PRASHANTHA
          AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
          S/O SHILAMANI
          R/AT BHANDARA HOUSE,
          BEJAI, MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
                                -4-
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    15.   DAYANANDA
          S/O CHENNAMMA ALIAS PARVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS
          R/AT BHANDARA HOUSE
          BEJAI, MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
    
    16.   GANGADHARA
          D/O CHENNAMMA ALIAS PARVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
          R/AT BHANDARA HOUSE
          BEJAI, MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
    
    17.   SUNDARI
          AGED ABOUT 96 YEARS
          D/O BALE ALIAS PONNAPPA
          R/AT MAROLI HITLU
          MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
    
    18.   HASKER
          AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
          S/O BALE ALIAS PONNAPPA
          R/AT MAROLI HITLU
          MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
    
    19.   DHARMARAJ
          AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
          S/O SUNDARI
          R/AT MAROLI HITLU
          MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
    
    20.   SURESH
          AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
          S/O SUNDARI
          R/AT MAROLI HITLU
          MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
    
    21.   LTHA
          AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
          D/O SUNDARI
          R/AT MAROLI HITLU
          MANGALORE - 575 004, D.K.
                                 -5-
                                         NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    22.   YASHAVANTHI
          AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
          D/O SUNDARI
          R/AT ANANDA SUVARNA HOUSE
          NEAR BHAGINI SAMAJA
          JEPPU MANGALORE - 575 002.
    
    23.   RASMI
          AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
          D/O YASHAVANTHI
          R/AT ANANDA SUVARNA HOUSE
          NEAR BHAGINI SAMAJA
          JEPPU MANGALORE - 575 002.
    
    24.   RAKSH
          AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
          D/O YASHAVANTHI
          R/AT ANANDA SUVARNA HOUSE
          NEAR BHAGINI SAMAJA
          JEPPU MANGALORE - 575 002.
    
    25.   SHAMBAVI
          AGED ABOUT 96 YEARS
          D/O LATE VENKAMMA
          R/AT KATTADAKODI HOUSE
          MAROLI, MANGALORE - 575 005.
    
    26.   INDIRA
          AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
          D/O LATE VENKAMMA
          R/AT KATTADAKODI HOUSE
          MAROLI, MANGALORE - 575 005.
    
          SHEKRA (SINCE DEAD)
          S/O LATE VENKAMMA.
    
          MANORAMA (SINCE DEAD)
          D/O LATE VENKAMMA.
    
    27.   SOMANATH
          AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
                               -6-
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
          S/O LATE PUTHAMMA
          R/AT KANTHAPPA MAISTRY COMPOUND
          MUNIYAL, KARKALA TALUK
          UDUPI DIST-574108.
    
    28.   THILOTHAMA
          AGED ABOUT 98 YEARS
          S/O LATE PUTHAMMA
          R/AT KANTHAPPA MAISTRY COMPOUND
          MUNIYAL, KARKALA TALUK
          UDUPI DIST-574108.
    
    29.   INDUMATHI ALIAS KUSUMAVATHY
          AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
          AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
          D/O LATE PUTHAMMA
          R/AT KANTHAPPA MAISTRY COMPOUND
          MUNIYAL, KARKALA TALUK
          UDUPI DIST-574108.
    
    30.   HARINA
          AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
          D/O LATE SHANTHI
          R/AT GEETHA MANDIRA
          GOKARNANATHA TEMPLE ROAD
          NEAR ALKE BRIDGE
          KUDROLI, MANGALORE - 575 002.
    
    31.   VINUTHA
          AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
          D/O HARINA
          R/AT GEETHA MANDIR
          GOKARNANATHA TEMPLE ROAD
          NEAR ALKE BRIDGE
          KUDROLI, MANGALORE - 575 002.
    
    32.   JYOTHSNA
          AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
          S/O HARINA
          R/AT GEETHA MANDIR
          GOKARNANATHA TEMPLE ROAD
                               -7-
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
          NEAR ALKE BRIDGE
          KUDROLI, MANGALORE - 575 002.
    
    33.   SHWETHA
          AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
          D/O HARINA
          R/AT GEETHA MANDIR
          GOKARNANATHA TEMPLE ROAD
          NEAR ALKE BRIDGE
          KUDROLI, MANGALORE - 575 002.
    
    34.   SUGANDHI
          AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
          D/O POOVAMMA
          R/AT MAROLI PADE
          KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    35.   MADHUSUDAN
          AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
          S/O SUGANDHI
          R/AT MAROLI PADE, KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    36.   RAJESH
          AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
          S/O SUGANDHI
          R/AT MAROLI PADE, KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    37.   CHANDAPPA ALIAS CHANDRAPPA
          AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS
          S/O POVAMMA
          R/AT MAROLI PADE, KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    38.   NAGESH AMIN
          AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
          S/O POOVAMMA
          R/AT MAROLI PADE, KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
                                -8-
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    39.   SHAGUNA ALIAS SAGUNA
          AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
          D/O POOVAMMA
          R/AT XAVIER LUIS COMPOUND
          KANDETTU, BIKARNAKATTE
          MANGALORE - 575 005, D.K.
    
    40.   UDAYA
          AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
          S/O SHAGUNA ALIAS SAGUNA
          R/AT XAVIER LUIS COMPOUND
          KANDETTU, BIKARNAKATTE
          MANGALORE - 575 005, D.K.
    
    41.   VIJAYA
          AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
          S/O SHAGUNA ALIAS SAGUNA
          R/AT XAVIER LUIS COMPOUND
          KANDETTU, BIKARNAKATTE
          MANGALORE - 575 005, D.K.
    
    42.   SHAMBAVI
          AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS
          D/O SIRIAMMAK
          R/AT C/O M THIMMAPPA
          DRIVER K.E.B.
          B.C.ROAD, BANTWAL - 574219, D.K.
    
    43.   DAYAVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
          D/O SHAMBAVI
          R/AT C/O M. THIMMAPPA
          DRIVER K.E.B.
          B.C.ROAD, BANTWAL - 574219, D.K.
    
    44.   SUNITHA
          AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
          D/O SHAMBAVI
          R/AT C/O M. THIMMAPPA
          DRIVER K.E.B.
          B.C.ROAD, BANTWAL - 574219, D.K.
                                 -9-
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    45.   PRAMILA
          AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
          D/O SHAMBAVI
          R/AT C/O M THIMMAPPA
          DRIVER K.E.B.
          B.C.ROAD, BANTWAL - 574219, D.K.
    
    46.   PRASHANTHA
          AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
          S/O SHAMBAVI
          R/AT C/O M THIMMAPPA
          DRIVER K.E.B.
          B.C.ROAD, BANTWAL - 574219, D.K.
    
    47.   CHANDRAVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
          D/O POOVAMMA
          R/AT NEAR N.A.V.P. SCHOOL
          PILIKUNJA, KASARGOD
          MANGALORE - 575008.
    
    48.   PURUSHOTHAMA AMIN
          AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
          D/O SIRIAMMK
          R/AT YEYYADI, BORBAIL
          MANGALORE - 575008, D.K.
    
    49.   YADAVA
          AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
          S/O SIRIAMMK
          R/AT MAROLI PADE
          KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575008.
    
    50.   KRISHNAPPA
          AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
          S/O SIRIAMMK
          R/AT MAROLI PADE
          KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575008.
                               - 10 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    51.   RUKMINI
          AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
          D/O SIRIAMMK
          R/AT. C/O. MONAPPA POOJARY
          PALLEMAJALU, P.O. MODANAUP
          B.C. ROAD, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K.-574211.
    
    52.   RAVI
          AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
          S/O RUKMINI
          R/AT. C/O. MONAPPA POOJARY
          PALLEMAJALU, P.O. MODANAUP
          B.C. ROAD, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K.-574211.
    
    53.   PREMA
          AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
          D/O SIRIAMMK
          R/AT MAROLI PADE, KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    54.   RATHNAKARA
          AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
          S/O PREMA
          R/AT MAROLI PADE, KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    55.   CHANDRAHASA
          AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
          S/O PREMA
          R/AT MAROLI PADE, KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    56.   RAMA BAI
          AGED ABOUT 85 YEARS
          D/O YAMUNA
          R/AT. SHIVA BAGH
          MERCARA HILL, MAROLI
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
                               - 11 -
                                          NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                           R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    57.   PRAFULLA
          AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
          D/O RAMA BAI
          R/AT. BEHIND 'G' RODI
          KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    58.   YASHODA
          AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
          D/O RAMA BAI
          R/AT. SHIVA BAGH, MERCARA HILL
          MAROLI, MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    59.   KISHANCHANDRA
          AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
          S/O PRAFULLA
          R/AT. BEHIND 'G' RODI
          KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    60.   SWATHI
          AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
          D/O PRAFULLA
          R/AT. BEHIND 'G' RODI
          KANKANADY
          MANGALORE - 575 002, D.K.
    
    61.   ANANDA
          AGED ABOUT 94 YEARS
          S/O MUNDYAPPA
          R/AT. SHIVA BAGH, MERCARA HILL
          MAROLI, MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    62.   MUTHAMMA
          AGED ABOUT 94 YEARS
          D/O ACHAPPU
          R/AT. AITHAPPA SAJIPA VILLAGE
          BOLLAI POST, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K.-574211.
                               - 12 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    63.   SUNANDA
          AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
          D/O MUTHAMMA
          R/AT. C/O. VENKAPPA POOJARY
          MALLAR, PONNEDADI
          ULAIBETTU POST
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    64.   PADMAVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
          D/O SUNANDA
          R/AT. C/O. VENKAPPA POOJARY
          MALLAR, PONNEDADI
          ULAIBETTU POST
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    65.   JANAMMA
          AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
          S/O SUNANDA
          R/AT. C/O. VENKAPPA POOJARY
          MALLAR, PONNEDADI
          ULAIBETTU POST
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    66.   MOHINI
          AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
          D/O SUNANDA
          R/AT. C/O. VENKAPPA POOJARY
          MALLAR, PONNEDADI
          ULAIBETTU POST
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    67.   PADMANABHA
          AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
          S/O SUNANDA
          R/AT. C/O. VENKAPPA POOJARY
          MALLAR, PONNEDADI
          ULAIBETTU POST
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
                                - 13 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    68.   HARISCHANDRA
          AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
          S/O SUNANDA
          R/AT. C/O. VENKAPPA POOJARY
          MALLAR, PONNEDADI
          ULAIBETTU POST
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    69.   ASHOKA
          AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
          S/O SUNANDA
          R/AT. C/O. VENKAPPA POOJARY
          MALLAR, PONNEDADI
          ULAIBETTU POST
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    70.   KUNHAPPA
          AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
          S/O MUTHAMMA
          R/AT. C/O. AITHAPPA SAJIPA VILLAGE
          BOLLAI POST, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    71.   PADMAPPA
          AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
          S/O MUTHAMMA
          R/AT. C/O. AITHAPPA SAJIPA VILLAGE
          BOLLAI POST, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    72.   GIRIYAPPA
          AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
          S/O MUTHAMMA
          R/AT. C/O. AITHAPPA SAJIPA VILLAGE
          BOLLAI POST, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    73.   KORAGAPPA ALIAS KOGGAPPA
          AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
          S/O MUTHAMMA
          R/AT. C/O. AITHAPPA SAJIPA VILLAGE
                              - 14 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
          BOLLAI POST, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    74.   SULOCHANA ALIAS SULOCHANI
          AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
          D/O MUTHAMMA
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    75.   MAMATHA
          AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
          D/O SULOCHANA ALIAS SULOCHANI
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    76.   PRAVINA
          AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
          S/O SULOCHANA ALIAS SULOCHANI
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    77.   SAVITHA
          AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
          D/O SULOCHANA ALIAS SULOCHANI
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    78.   GANGAYYA
          AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
          S/O MUTHAMMA
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
                              - 15 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    79.   KRISHNAMMA
          AGED ABOUT 89 YEARS
          D/O ACHAPPU
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    80.   REVATHI
          AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
          D/O KRISHNAMMA
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    81.   ROHINI
          AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
          D/O REVATHI
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    82.   VASANTHA
          AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
          S/O REVATHI
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    83.   JAYALAXMI
          AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
          D/O REVATHI
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
                                 - 16 -
                                          NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                           R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    84.   ASHALATHA
          AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
          D/O REVATHI
          R/AT C/O. SRIDHARA POOJARY
          KEMPU GUDDE, AMTADY VILLAGE
          POST KINNIBETU, BANTWAL TALUK
          D.K. - 574211.
    
    85.   NALINI
          AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
          D/O KRISHNAMMA
          R/AT C/O. RAMA POOJARY, IRAJE
          VAIL JOUSE, KALIGE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    86.   MAHABALA
          AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
          S/O NALINI
          R/AT C/O. RAMA POOJARY, IRAJE
          VAIL JOUSE, KALIGE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    87.   LATHA
          AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
          D/O NALINI
          R/AT C/O. RAMA POOJARY, IRAJE
          VAIL JOUSE, KALIGE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    88.   GEETHA
          AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
          D/O NALINI
          R/AT C/O. RAMA POOJARY, IRAJE
          VAIL JOUSE, KALIGE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    89.   NEETHA
          AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
          D/O NALINI
                                 - 17 -
                                          NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                           R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
          R/AT C/O. RAMA POOJARY, IRAJE
          VAIL JOUSE, KALIGE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    90.   ASHWITHA
          AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
          D/O NALINI
          R/AT C/O. RAMA POOJARY, IRAJE
          VAIL JOUSE, KALIGE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    91.   NAMITHA
          AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
          D/O NALINI
          R/AT C/O. RAMA POOJARY, IRAJE
          VAIL JOUSE, KALIGE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    92.   SUNANDA
          AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
          D/O KRISHNAMMA
          R/AT C/O. GIRIYAPPA POOJARY
          KARMAR HOUSE, BALILA VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    93.   LOLAKSHI
          AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
          D/O SUNANDA
          R/AT C/O. GIRIYAPPA POOJARY
          KARMAR HOUSE, BALILA VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    94.   MOHANDAS
          AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
          S/O SUNANDA
          R/AT C/O. GIRIYAPPA POOJARY
          KARMAR HOUSE, BALILA VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    95.   SUDHAKSHI
          AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
                               - 18 -
                                         NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
          D/O SUNANDA
          R/AT C/O. GIRIYAPPA POOJARY
          KARMAR HOUSE, BALILA VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    96.   MURALIDHARA
          AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
          S/O SUNANDA
          R/AT C/O. GIRIYAPPA POOJARY
          KARMAR HOUSE, BALILA VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    97.   CHIDANANDA
          AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
          S/O SUNANDA
          R/AT C/O. GIRIYAPPA POOJARY
          KARMAR HOUSE, BALILA VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    98.   JARAPPA ALILAS DARAPPA
          AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
          S/O KRISHNAMMA
          R/AT. C/O. GANAPA POOJARY
          GANADA KOTYA HOUSE
          THUMBE VILLAGE
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    99.   PREMA
          AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
          D/O KRISHNAMMA
          R/AT. C/O. NARAYANA POOJARY
          DOOR NO.209, NEAR D.C. BUNGALOW
          BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    100. SHARMILA
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         D/O PREMA
         R/AT. C/O. NARAYANA POOJARY
         DOOR NO.209, NEAR D.C. BUNGALOW
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
                              - 19 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    101. SHRATH
         AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
         S/O PREMA
         R/AT. C/O. NARAYANA POOJARY
         DOOR NO.209, NEAR D.C. BUNGALOW
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    102. BABY
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT. DARANDA BAGILU HOUSE
         HOSAGUDDE, POST THOKKOTTU
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574211.
    
    103. YATHIN KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         S/O BABY
         R/AT. DARANDA BAGILU HOUSE
         HOSAGUDDE, POST THOKKOTTU
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574211.
    
    104. PRAFULL
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. GANAPA POOJARY
         GANADA KOTYA HOUSE
         THUMBE VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.-574211.
    
    105. NAGAMMA
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         D/O ACHAPPU
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    106. PADMANBHA
         AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
         S/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
                                - 20 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         BANTWAL TALUK,
         D.K.574211.
    
    107. CHANDRAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         D/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    108. SUNDARA
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         S/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    109. MONAPPA
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
         S/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    110. KOMALA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    111. UMESHA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    112. JANARDHANA
         AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
         S/O NAGAMMA
                             - 21 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    113. SHAMBYYA OBAYYA
         AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
         S/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    114. HARISHA
         AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
         S/O CHANDRAVATHI
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    115. GIRISH
         AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
         S/O CHANDRAVATHI
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    116. SURESHA
         AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
         S/O CHANDRAVATHI
         R/AT C/O. KANYAPPA POOJARY
         BALEMANE, CHELURU VILLAGE
         BANTWAL TALUK, D.K.574211.
    
    117. RATHNA RAJ
         AGED ABOUT 87 YEARS
         D/O LATE RUKKU
         R/AT AMIN NIVAS, VIHAR COLONY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    118. VENKATESH
         AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
         S/O RATHANA BAI
         R/AT AMIN NIVAS, VIHAR COLONY
                             - 22 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    
    119. JAGANNATHA
         AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
         S/O RATHANA BAI
         R/AT AMIN NIVAS, VIHAR COLONY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    120. SUMITHRA
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         S/O RATHANA BAI
         R/AT NEAR L.F. BRIDGE
         PUMPWELL, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    121. NAINA
         AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
         D/O RATHANA BAI
         R/AT AMIN NIVAS, VIHAR COLONY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    122. BHAVANI
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O RATHANA BAI
         R/AT AMIN NIVAS, VIHAR COLONY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    123. RAKSHITA
         AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
         D/O SUMITHRA
         R/AT NEAR L.F. BRIDGE
         PUMPWELL, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    124. DHANALAXMI
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         D/O SUMITHRA
         R/AT NEAR L.F. BRIDGE
         PUMPWELL, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
                             - 23 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    125. KOGGAPPA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 85 YEARS
         S/O LATE SEETHAMMA
         R/AT NEAR L.F. BRIDGE
         PUMPWELL, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    126. SUMATHI ALIAS SULOCHANA
         AGED ABOUT 82 YEARS
         D/O LATE SEETHAMMA
         R/AT NEAR R.B. BUNGLOW
         KANKANADY, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575002.
    
    127. ROSHAN PRASAD
         AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
         S/O LATE SEETHAMMA
         R/AT DWARAKA HOUSE
         V BLOCK, KRISHNAPUR
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575014.
    
    128. POORNIMA
         AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
         D/O LATE SEETHAMMA
         R/AT DWARAKA HOUSE
         V BLOCK, KRISHNAPUR
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575014.
    
    129. NISHUMATHI
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         D/O LATE SEETHAMMA
         R/AT DWARAKA HOUSE
         V BLOCK, KRISHNAPUR
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575014.
    
    130. JANARDHANA
         AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
         S/O LATE LAXMI
         R/AT RAMA NAIK COMPOUND
         MULIHITHLU, BOLAR
                              - 24 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         MANGALORE, D.K-575001.
    
    
    131. PUSHPAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 87 YEARS
         D/O LEELAVATHI
         R/AT C/O. K. POOVAPPA
         D.NO.183 (ROOM NO.9)
         POLICE QUARTERS
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    132. BHAGAVANADAS
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         S/O PUSHPAVATHI
         R/AT C/O. K. POOVAPPA
         D.NO.183 (ROOM NO.9)
         POLICE QUARTERS
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    133. GOPIDAS
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         S/O PUSHPAVATHI
         R/AT C/O. K. POOVAPPA
         D.NO.183 (ROOM NO.9)
         POLICE QUARTERS
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    134. PRASAD KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         S/O LATE LEELAVATHI
         R/AT BALAGURI, KAVOOR
         PADAVU, P.O. KAVOOR
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575006.
    
    135. AJITH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         S/O LATE LEELAVATHI
         R/AT SENIOR ASSISTANT
         C/O. C.P.C. COMPANY
         POST VITTAL, D.K.-574243
                              - 25 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         B. MAHALAXMI (SINCE DEAD)
         D/O LATE KRISHNAMMA.
    
    136. SATHYENDRA
         AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
         S/O B. MAHALAXMI
         R/AT PUNJALKATTE
         POST PUNJALKATTE
         MANGALORE, D.K - 575004.
    
    137. BHARATHENDRA
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         S/O B. MAHALAXMI
         R/AT VAS COMPOUND
         BIKARNKATTE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    138. RAVIRAJ
         AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
         S/O B. MAHALAXMI
         R/AT PUNJALKATTE
         POST PUNJALKATTE
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    139. HARINAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         D/O B. MAHALAXMI
         R/AT C/O. U.L. ANCHAN
         MANU NEAR GOKUL HALL
         ASHOKANAGARA
         MANGALORE, D.K. - 575004.
    
    140. NRIPARAJA
         AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
         S/O B. MAHALAXMI
         R/AT C/O. U.L. ANCHAN
         MANU NEAR GOKUL HALL
         ASHOKANAGARA
         MANGALORE, D.K. - 575004.
                                - 26 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    141. RAJESHWARI
         AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS
         S/O B. MAHALAXMI
         R/AT NEAR DEVIGUDI
         ASHOKANAGARA
         MANGALORE, D.K. - 575004.
    
    142. MANOHARI
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         D/O B. MAHALAXMI
         R/AT NEAR DEVIGUDI
         ASHOKANAGAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    143. ROOPAREKHA
         AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
         D/O HARINAKSHI
         R/AT. CLEARK CUM TYPIST
         CORPORATION BANK
         PANDESHWAR, MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    144. CHITRALEKHA
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O HARINAKSHI
         R/AT C/O. U.L. ANCHAN
         MANU NEAR GOKUL HALL
         ASHOKANAGAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    145. MANOHARA
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         S/O HARINAKSHI
         R/AT C/O. U.L. ANCHAN
         MANU NEAR GOKUL HALL
         ASHOKANAGAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    146. SANTHOSH
         AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
         S/O RAJESHWARI
         R/AT NEAR DEVIGUDI
                              - 27 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         ASHOKANAGAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    
    147. BHAGAWAN
         AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
         S/O RAJESHWARI
         R/AT NEAR DEVIGUDI
         ASHOKANAGAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    148. SUCHITRA
         AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
         D/O RAJESHWARI
         R/AT NEAR DEVIGUDI
         ASHOKANAGAR
         MANGALORE, D.K. 575004.
    
         RAMACHANDRA (SINCE DEAD)
         S/O LATE KRISHNAMMA.
    
         SUSHEELA (SINCE DEAD)
         D/O LATE KRISHNAMMA.
    
    149. SHANTHI
         AGED ABOUT 98 YEARS
         D/O LATE KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. B. BABU, MAROLI
         KAIKAMBA, MANGALORE, D.K. 575004.
    
         SATISH (SINCE DEAD)
         S/O LATE KRISHNAMMA.
    
    150. CHANDRAPRABHA
         AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
         D/O LATE KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. VISHWANATHA
         NEAR BANDIKOTYA
         MALLARAYA, DEVASTHAN
         ULLAL, D.K.-575020.
                               - 28 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    151. ARUNAKARA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O LATE KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. B. BABU MAROLI
         KAIKAMBA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    152. SUDHAKARA
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         S/O LATE KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. B. BABU MAROLI
         KAIKAMBA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    153. BHAVANISHAKER
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         S/O LATE KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. B. BABU MAROLI
         KAIKAMBA, MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    154. SHOBHAMANI
         AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
         D/O LATE KRISHNAMMA
         R/AT C/O. B. BABU MAROLI
         KAIKAMBA, MANGALORE, D.K-575005.
    
    155. YOGITHA
         AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
         D/O CHANDRAPRABHA
         R/AT C/O. VISHWANATHA
         NEAR BANDIKOTYA
         MALLARAYA, DEVASTHAN
         ULLAL, D.K. 575020.
    
    156. PURUSHOTHAMA
         AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
         S/O CHANDRAPRABHA
         R/AT C/O. VISHWANATHA
         NEAR BANDIKOTYA
         MALLARAYA, DEVASTHAN
         ULLAL, D.K.-575020.
                                - 29 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    157. GIRISHA
         AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
         S/O CHANDRAPRABHA
         R/AT C/O. VISHWANATHA
         NEAR BANDIKOTYA
         MALLARAYA, DEVASTHAN
         ULLAL, D.K.-575020.
    
    158. SOWMYA
         AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
         D/O SHANTHI
         R/AT C/O. B. BABU MAROLI
         KAIKAMBA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    159. ROHINI
         AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
         D/O LATE GNGAMMA
         R/AT NEAR MAROLLI
         KAIKAMBA, BIKARNAKATTE
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    160. ANITHA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O ROHINI
         R/AT NEAR MAROLLI, KAIKAMBA
         BIKARNAKATTE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    161. CHITTARANJAN
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O ROHINI
         R/AT NEAR MAROLLI, KAIKAMBA
         BIKARNAKATTE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.- 575004.
    
    162. PRABHAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 91 YEARS
         D/O LATE BHAVANI
                              - 30 -
                                         NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT LINGAPPA COMPOUND
         GANAPATHY TEMPLE ROAD
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    163. YAMUNA
         AGED ABOUT 98 YEARS
         D/O LATE DASAMMA
         R/AT NEAR MAROLLI, KAIKAMBA
         BIKARNAKATTE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    164. PADMANABHA
         AGED ABOUT 99 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENDRAMMA
         R/AT C/O. SUMATHI ANCHAN
         DEVIKRIPA NEAR PRABHA BHAVAN
         SOMESHWAR, UCHIL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575023.
    
    165. SUNDRI
         AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS
         D/O LATE CHENDRAMMA
         R/AT A SHEENA, ALAPE
         PADIL, MANGALORE, D.K.575007.
    
    166. SEETHA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHARADA
         R/AT. KAVOOR POST
         KAVOOR VILLAGE
         MANGALORE, D.K.575006.
    
    167. REVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHARADA
         R/AT C/O. VISHVANTH
         KANTHAPPA COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
                              - 31 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    168. JANAKI
         AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHARADA
         R/AT C/O. VISHVANTH
         KANTHAPPA COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    169. SUMATHI
         AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHARADA
         R/AT C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    170. MOHINI
         AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHARADA
         R/AT C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    171. GANESHA
         AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
         S/O SUNDRI
         R/AT. C/O. A. SHEENA, ALAPE
         PADIL, MANGALORE, D.K.-575007.
    
    172. DINESHA
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         S/O SUNDRI
         R/AT. C/O. A. SHEENA, ALAPE
         PADIL, MANGALORE, D.K.-575007.
    
    173. JAGADISH
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         S/O SUNDRI
         R/AT. C/O. A. SHEENA, ALAPE
         PADIL, MANGALORE, D.K.-575007.
                               - 32 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    174. MALATHI
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O SUNDRI
         R/AT. C/O. A. SHEENA, ALAPE
         PADIL, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575007.
    
    175. DAYAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O SUNDRI
         R/AT. C/O. A. SHEENA, ALAPE
         PADIL, MANGALORE, D.K.-575007.
    
    176. JAYASHREE
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O SEETHA
         R/AT. NEAR KAVOOR POST
         KAVOOR VILLAGE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575006.
    
    177. SHAILAJA
         AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
         D/O SEETHA
         R/AT. NEAR KAVOOR POST
         KAVOOR VILLAGE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575006.
    
    178. SARITHA
         AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
         D/O SEETHA
         R/AT. NEAR KAVOOR POST
         KAVOOR VILLAGE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575006.
    
    179. YATHISHA
         AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
         D/O SEETHA
         R/AT. NEAR KAVOOR POST
         KAVOOR VILLAGE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575006.
                            - 33 -
                                    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    180. DHARESHA
         AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
         S/O SUMATHI
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    181. NARESH
         AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
         S/O SUMATHI
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    182. LATHIS
         AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
         S/O SUMATHI
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    183. PRAVEEN
         AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
         S/O JANAKI
         R/AT. C/O. VISHVANTH
         KANTHAPPA COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    184. PRAJNA
         AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
         R/AT. C/O. VISHVANTH
         KANTHAPPA COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
                             - 34 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    185. LOHITHA
         AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
         S/O SUMATHI
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
         NAGAMMA (SINCE DEAD )
         D/O LATE KOCHU.
    
    186. ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         AGED ABOUT 113 YEARS
         S/O LATE KOCHU
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    187. SUBRAYA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 111 YEARS
         S/O LATE KOCHU
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    188. GANGA
         AGED ABOUT 103 YEARS
         S/O LATE KOCHU
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    189. SUNDARI
         AGED ABOUT 99 YEARS
         S/O LATE KOCHU
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
                             - 35 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    190. KRISHNAMMA
         AGED ABOUT 95 YEARS
         D/O LATE KOCHU
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    191. PARVATHY
         AGED ABOUT 95 YEARS
         D/O LATE NAGAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
         SARASWATHY
         SINCE DEAD.
    
    192. LEELA
         AGED ABOUT 91 YEARS
         D/O LATE NAGAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    193. JAYANTHI
         AGED ABOUT 82 YEARS
         D/O LATE NAGAMMA
         R/AT. C/O. BHUJANGA
         MARKADE HOUSE, KRISHNANAGAR
         BONDEL POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    194. TARAVATHY
         AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
         S/O LATE BHAVANI
         R/AT. MARY HILL, KONCHADY POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
                              - 36 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    195. HEMAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
         D/O GANGA
         R/AT. KARIYAPPA POOJARY
         KOTI POOJARY COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    196. KORAGAPPA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O GANGA
         R/AT. KONGOOR HOUSE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    197. KESHAVA
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         S/O GANGA
         R/AT. C/O. RAMA, KIRODIAN
         ASHOKANAGAR
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575006.
    
    198. SURENDRA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARI
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCONUT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    199. NAGESH AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARI
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT COCONUT
         GARDEN, KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.575002.
    
    200. ROHITHASHWA
         AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARI
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT COCONUT
                               - 37 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         GARDEN, KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.575002.
    
    201. RAMADAS AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARI
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT COCONUT
         GARDEN, KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.575002.
    
    202. UMESHA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARI
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT COCONUT
         GARDEN, KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.575002.
    
    203. LEELADHARA
         AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS
         S/O PARVATHY
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.575003.
    
    204. MANOJ
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         S/O PARVATHY
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.575003.
    
    205. YASHAVANTHI
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         S/O PARVATHY
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.575003.
    
    206. NARAYANA
         AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHY
                             - 38 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. C/O. CHANDAYYA POOJARY
         BOLEPUGUDDE HOUSE
         KAVOOR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575004.
    
    207. DEVARAJA
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHY
         R/AT. C/O. CHANDAYYA POOJARY
         BOLEPUGUDDE HOUSE
         KAVOOR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575004.
    
    208. SUSHEELA
         AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
         D/O LATE SARASWATHY
         R/AT. C/O. CHANDAYYA POOJARY
         BOLEPUGUDDE HOUSE
         KAVOOR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575004.
    
    209. MANOHARA
         AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHY
         R/AT. C/O. CHANDAYYA POOJARY
         BOLEPUGUDDE HOUSE
         KAVOOR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575004.
    
    210. VASANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
         D/O LATE SARASWATHY
         R/AT. C/O. CHANDAYYA POOJARY
         BOLEPUGUDDE HOUSE
         KAVOOR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575004.
    
    211. SARALA
         AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
         D/O LATE SARASWATHY
         R/AT. SHIVANANDA PANDIT SWAMY
                               - 39 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         PRASD HOUSE, THALAPADY
         KINIGOLI, UDUPI-574150.
    
    212. SURESH
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHY
         R/AT. C/O. CHANDAYYA POOJARY
         BOLEPUGUDDE HOUSE
         KAVOOR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575004.
    
    213. HARISCHANDRA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHY
         R/AT. C/O. CHANDAYYA POOJARY
         BOLEPUGUDDE HOUSE
         KAVOOR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575004.
    
    214. KRISHNAVENI
         AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
         D/O LEELA
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
    
    215. YADAVA
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         S/O LEELA
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
    
    216. VINODA
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         S/O LEELA
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
                               - 40 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    217. SHIVANANDA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O LEELA
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
         DEVADAS
         SINCE DEAD
         S/O TARAVATHY
    
    218. SUREKHA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O TARAVATHY
         R/AT. NEAR V.S.S.S. SANGHA
         BANTWALA, D.K.-575211.
    
    219. HARISHA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         S/O TARAVATHY
         R/AT. MARY HILL
         KONCHADY POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    220. LATHA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O TARAVATHY
         R/AT. MARY HILL
         KONCHADY POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    221. ASHA
         AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
         D/O TARAVATHY
         R/AT. MARY HILL
         KONCHADY POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    222. RENUKA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O HEMAVATHI
         R/AT. KARIYAPPA POOJARY
                                - 41 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         KOTI POOJARY COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    223. YASHAVANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O HEMAVATHI
         R/AT. KARIYAPPA POOJARY
         KOTI POOJARY COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    224. JAYASHREE
         AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
         D/O HEMAVATHI
         R/AT. KARIYAPPA POOJARY
         KOTI POOJARY COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    225. HARISHA
         AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
         S/O HEMAVATHI
         R/AT. KARIYAPPA POOJARY
         KOTI POOJARY COMPOUND
         KULASHEKAR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    226. UMESHA
         AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. RAMA MAISTRY
         BOLAPAGUTHU HOUSE
         DANDEKARI, KONCHADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    227. KAMALAKSHA
         AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. RAMA MAISTRY
         BOLAPAGUTHU HOUSE
                               - 42 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         DANDEKARI, KONCHADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    228. SADANANDA
         AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. RAMA MAISTRY
         BOLAPAGUTHU HOUSE
         DANDEKARI, KONCHADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    229. SUMAN
         AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. RAMA MAISTRY
         BOLAPAGUTHU HOUSE
         DANDEKARI, KONCHADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    230. MOHAN
         AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. RAMA MAISTRY
         BOLAPAGUTHU HOUSE
         DANDEKARI, KONCHADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    231. LOHITH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         S/O SARALA
         R/AT. SHIVANANDA PANDI SWAMY
         PRASD HOUSE, THALAPADY
         KINIGOLI, UDUPI-574150.
    
    232. SHARATH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
         S/O KRISHNAVENI
         R/AT. NEAR SRI OIL MILLS
         BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
                               - 43 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    233. NITHIN
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         S/O SUREKHA
         R/AT. NEAR V.S.S. SANGHA
         BANTAWAL, D.K.-575211.
    
    234. LOLAMMA
         AGED ABOUT 99 YEARS
         D/O POOVAPPA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
         SUNDARI
         SINCE DEAD
         D/O LATE POOVAPPA.
    
    235. PUTHAMMA
         AGED ABOUT 87 YEARS
         D/O POOVAPPA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    236. JAYANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS
         S/O LATE POOVAPPA
         R/AT. SAI NILAYA
         OPPOSITE BEJAI CHURCH
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    
    237. DEVAKE
         AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
         D/O POOVAPPA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
                             - 44 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    238. LEELA
         AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
         D/O POOVAPPA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    239. RAMA
         AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
         D/O POOVAPPA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    240. JALAJAKSH
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O PUTHAMMA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    241. HARIDASA
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         S/O LATE MUTHU
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    242. MEENAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         D/O LATE MUTHU
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
                                - 45 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    243. PURUSHOTHAMMA
         AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
         D/O LATE MUTHU
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    244. KEIAHNA VENI
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         D/O LATE MUTHU
         R/AT. MAROLI DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    245. VIJAYA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O LATE MUTHU
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    246. DURGADAS
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         S/O LATE MUTHU
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    247. SHEKARA
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         S/O PUTHAMMA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    248. KESHAVA
         AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
                             - 46 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         S/O PUTHAMMA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    249. JAYANTHI
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         S/O PUTHAMMA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    250. PREMNATH
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         S/O DEVAKE
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    251. RAMESH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         S/O DEVAKE
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    252. MAHALAXMI
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O DEVAKE
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    253. TRIVENI
         AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
         D/O DEVAKE
                             - 47 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    254. DIVAKARA
         AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
         S/O DEVAKE
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
         NALINAKSHI
         SINCE DEAD
         D/O DEVAKE.
    
    255. SHEELAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
         D/O DEVAKE
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    256. BALAKRISHNA
         AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
         S/O DEVAKE
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    257. PRASHANTH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         S/O LEELA
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
                             - 48 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    258. CHETAN KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
         S/O MEENAKSHI
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    259. MITHUN KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
         S/O MEENAKSHI
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    260. PADMASHREE
         AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
         D/O MEENAKSHI
         R/AT. DEVIKRIPA
         PACHANADY VILLAGE
         BONDEL POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575008.
    
    261. SHARATH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
         S/O KEIAHNAVENI
         R/AT. MAROLI DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    262. ANANDA
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         S/O KANAPAYA
         R/AT. C/O. GEEHA BHAVAN
         YEYYADI PADAV, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    263. SANJEEVA
         AGED ABOUT 95 YEARS
         S/O MANYAPPE ALIAS MANJAPPE
                             - 49 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. NEAR JEPPINAMOGARU SCHOOL
         POST KANKANADY, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575008.
    
    264. KUMUDA
         AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
         W/O SURENDRA AMIN
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCONUT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002
    
    265. AKSHATHA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O SURENDRA AMIN
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCOUNT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    266. NEVEDITHA
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
         D/O SURENDRA AMIN
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCOUNT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    267. SHARATH
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O SURENDRA AMIN
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCOUNT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    268. CHANDRAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
         W/O ROHITHASHWA
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCOUNT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    269. PRETHISH
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
                             - 50 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         S/O ROHITHASHWA
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCOUNT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    270. PRIYA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O ROHITHASHWA
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCOUNT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    271. PRITHIKA
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
         S/O ROHITHASHWA
         R/AT. NEAR GOVT., COCOUNT
         GARDEN KADRI, KANKANADY
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575002.
    
    272. JAYANTHI BELOOR
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         D/O NAGAMMA
         R/AT. BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
    
    273. PARVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         D/O JAYANTHI
         R/AT. BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
    
    274. LEELA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O JAYANTHI
         R/AT. BOLOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575003.
    
    275. GIRIJA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         W/O KORAGAPPA AMIN
         R/AT. KONGOOR HOUSE
                                - 51 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    276. MANJULA
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         D/O GIRIJA
         R/AT. KONGOOR HOUSE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    277. JAYAPRABHA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O GIRIJA
         R/AT. KONGOOR HOUSE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    278. USHA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         W/O KESHAVA
         R/AT. KONGOOR HOUSE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    279. SOWMYA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O KESHAVA
         R/AT. KONGOOR HOUSE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    280. SAPNA
         AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
         D/O KESHAVA
         R/AT. KONGOOR HOUSE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    281. GAYATHRI
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         W/O DEVADAS
                             - 52 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. KANOOR, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    282. LAXMI
         AGED ABOUT 99 YEARS
         W/O SUNDARA
         R/AT. MAROLI, DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    283. NAGESH ANCHAN
         AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARA
         R/AT. MAROLI, DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    284. LALITHA
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         D/O SUNDARA
         R/AT. MAROLI, DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    285. LAXMANA
         AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARA
         R/AT. MAROLI, DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    286. ANANDA
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARA
         R/AT. MAROLI, DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    287. CHANDRASHEKAR
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARA
                             - 53 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. MAROLI, DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    288. NAVEENCHANDRA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O SUNDARA
         R/AT. MAROLI, DODDAMANE
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    289. T. GIRIJA
         AGED ABOUT 88 YEARS
         W/O LATE SHEKARA
         R/AT. KATTADAKODI HOUSE
         MAROLI, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    290. SANTHOSH
         AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
         S/O LATE SHEKARA
         R/AT. KATTADAKODI HOUSE
         MAROLI, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    291. M. SHIVAPRASAD
         AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
         S/O LATE SHEKARA
         R/AT. KATTADAKODI HOUSE
         MAROLI, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    292. M. PUSHPA RAJ
         AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
         S/O LATE SHEKARA
         R/AT. KATTADAKODI HOUSE
         MAROLI, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    293. SHARNYA
         AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
                             - 54 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         D/O LATE SHEKARA
         R/AT. KATTADAKODI HOUSE
         MAROLI, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    294. YAMUNA
         AGED ABOUT 111 YEARS
         W/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    295. PREMALATHA
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         D/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    296. VEDAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 91 YEARS
         D/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    297. UMANATH
         AGED ABOUT 90 YEARS
         S/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    298. CHANDRAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 88 YEARS
         S/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
                             - 55 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    299. JAYAVEERA
         AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
         S/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    300. SATHISHA
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         D/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    301. SHAMALA
         AGED ABOUT 82 YEARS
         D/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    302. NARENDRA
         AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS
         D/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    303. POORNIMA
         AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
         D/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    304. DINESHA
         AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS
         S/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
                             - 56 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    305. VISHALAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
         D/O ACHUTHA AMIN ALIAS ACHU
         R/AT. JAYASHREE GATE
         BIKARNKATTA, MANGALORE
         D.K.-575005.
    
    306. CHANDRAKANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    307. NARAYANA
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    308. DEVARAJ
         AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    309. SUSHEELA
         AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS
         D/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    310. MANOHR
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    311. VASANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         D/O LATE SARASWATHI
                                - 57 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    312. SARALA
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         D/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    313. SURESHA
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    314. HARISCHANDRA
         AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
         S/O LATE SARASWATHI
         R/AT. BALEPU GUDDE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575015.
    
    315. SACHINDRA
         AGED ABOUT 96 YEARS
         S/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    
    316. BARATENDRA
         AGED ABOUT 94 YEARS
         S/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    
    317. RAVIRAJ
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         S/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    
    318. HARINAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 91 YEARS
                             - 58 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         S/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    
    319. NRAPARAJ
         AGED ABOUT 89 YEARS
         S/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    320. RAJESHWARI
         AGED ABOUT 92 YEARS
         D/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    
    321. MANOHARI
         AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
         D/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    
    322. VASUKUMARI
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         D/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. PUNJALKATTE POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-574233.
    
    323. JAIRAJ
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. KAIKAMBA
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    324. JEEVARATHANA
         AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. KAIKAMBA
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
                             - 59 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    325. SUNDARI BAI
         AGED ABOUT 108 YEARS
         W/O LATE RAMACHANDRA
         R/AT. SAVITHRI NILAYA
         OLD KEN ROAD
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    326. SHASHIKANTH
         AGED ABOUT 105 YEARS
         S/O LATE SAVITHRI
         R/AT. SAVITHRI NILAYA
         OLD KEN ROAD
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    327. CHANDRAKALA
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         W/O LATE RAMACHANDRA
         R/AT. SAVITHRI NILAYA
         OLD KEN ROAD
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    328. NAVEEN
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         S/O LATE RAMACHANDRA
         R/AT. SAVITHRI NILAYA
         OLD KEN ROAD
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    329. PRADEEP
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         S/O LATE RAMACHANDRA
         R/AT. SAVITHRI NILAYA
         OLD KEN ROAD
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575001.
    
    330. ROHINI
         AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
         W/O LATE SATISH
         R/AT. MAROLIKAIKAMBA
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
                                - 60 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    331. PRAJVITHA
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
         S/O LATE SATISH
         R/AT. MAROLIKAIKAMBA
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    
    332. AKSHTHA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O LATE SATISH
         R/AT. MAROLIKAIKAMBA
         KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575005.
    
    333. BHUJANGA
         AGED ABOUT 101 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT. BHANDARA MANE, BEJAI
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    
    334. GIRIJA
         AGED ABOUT 96 YEARS
         D/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT. BHANDARA MANE, BEJAI
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    
    335. K. PADMANABHA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT. BHANDARA MANE, BEJAI
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    
    336. VASANTHI
         AGED ABOUT 92 YEARS
         D/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
                                - 61 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. BHANDARA MANE, BEJAI
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    
    337. AMRUTHA
         AGED ABOUT 85 YEARS
         D/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT. BHANDARA MANE, BEJAI
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    338. ASHOKA
         AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT. BHANDARA MANE, BEJAI
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    
    339. SUCHARITHA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         D/O LATE MANORAMA
         R/AT MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    340. ROSHAN
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         S/O LATE MANORAMA
         R/AT MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    341. THARESH
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         S/O LATE MANORAMA
         R/AT MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    342. VISHALA
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         D/O LATE MANORAMA
          R/AT MAROLI
                              - 62 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         DODDAMANE, KULASHEKAR POST
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    343. SHEKARA
         AGED ABOUT 92 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT. MONAPPA COMPOUND
         MARNAMIKATTE
         MANGALORE, D.K.-575004.
    
    344. BHJANGA ALIAS SUNDARA
         AGED ABOUT 90 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT MUNDA COLONY
         BLOCK NO 10, ROOM NO 6
         POWY SQUARE, BOMBAY 400082.
    
    345. RAMACHANDRA
         AGED ABOUT 88 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT NO 355, 10TH CROSS
         III STAGE, GOKULAM
         MYSORE 570002.
    
    346. PURUSHOTHAMA
         AGED ABOUT 88 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT SUPERVISOR, SOETS LTD.,
         THANE, MAHARASHTRA-400066.
    
    347. GOPALAKRISHNA
         AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT MANAGER VIJAYA BANK
         NAGAPPA BLOCK
         BANGALORE 560021.
                                - 63 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    348. AMRITH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT C/O GOVT., TOOL ROOM
         AND TRAINING CENTRE
         RAJAJI NAGAR INDUSTRIAL ESTATE
         BANGALORE-560044.
    349. ASHOK KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
         S/O LATE CHENNAMMA
         ALIAS PARVATHI
         R/AT 15A, GANESH LEELA
         NEAR BHARGAVI TEMPLE
         KELWA WEST, BOMBAY 400088.
    
    350. YASHODA
         AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
         D/O LATE SEETHAMMA
         R/AT PRASHANTH KUTEERA
         BHARATHINAGAR
         DHARWAD 580004.
    
    351. SOMASUNDARA
         AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
         D/O LATE SEETHAMMA
         R/AT. PRASHANTH KUTEERA
         BHARATHINAGAR
         DHARWAD 580004.
    
    352. PRASHANTH
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         D/O YASHODA
         R/AT PRASHANTH KUTEERA
         BHARATHINAGAR
         DHARWAD 580004.
    
    353. PAVITHRA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O YASHODA
                              - 64 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                       R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT PRASHANTH KUTEERA
         BHARATHINAGAR
         DHARWAD 580004.
    
    354. THRIVENI
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O YASHODA
         R/AT PRASHANTH KUTEERA
         BHARATHINAGAR
         DHARWAD 580004.
    
    355. VASANTHA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O INDIRA
         R/AT C9-2, NITHIN BUILDING
         GEETHANJALI NAGAR
         S.V. ROAD, BORIVILE WEST
         BOMBAY 400071.
    
    356. SUCHARITHA
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         D/O MANORAMA
         R/AT J-543, 6TH FLOOR
         RESERVE BANK OF INDIA QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    357. ABHIJITH
         AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
         S/O SUCHARITHA
         R/AT J-543, 6TH FLOOR
         RESERVE BANK OF INDIA QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    358. NIHAL
         AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
         S/O SUCHARITHA
         R/AT J-543, 6TH FLOOR
         RESERVE BANK OF INDIA QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY 400071.
                               - 65 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    359. TARESH
         AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
         S/O MANORAMA
         R/AT J-543, 6TH FLOOR
         RESERVE BANK OF INDIA QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    360. ROHAN
         AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
         S/O MANORAMA
         R/AT J-543, 6TH FLOOR
         RESERVE BANK OF INDIA QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    361. VISHALA
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         S/O MANORAMA
         R/AT J-543, 6TH FLOOR
         RESERVE BANK OF INDIA QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    362. NONIP
         AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
         S/O VISHALA
         R/AT J-543, 6TH FLOOR
         RESERVE BANK OF INDIA QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    363. DIVAKARA
         AGED ABOUT 87 YEARS
         S/O LATE VENKAMMA
         R/AT. #11, B.A.R.C. QUARTERS
         BYCULLA, BOMBAY-400008.
    
    364. JANARDHAN
         AGED ABOUT 98 YEARS
         D/O LATE PUTHAMMA
         R/AT 7-2-2, TATA HOUSING
         CENTRE, LULLUBHAI PARK ROAD
         ANDERI WEST, BOMBAY 400058.
                             - 66 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    365. ROHINI ALIAS MOHINI
         AGED ABOUT 90 YEARS
         D/O LATE PUTHAMMA
         R/AT G-2, TATA HOUSING
         CENTRE, LULLUBHAI PARK ROAD
         ANDERI WEST, BOMBAY 400058.
    
    366. PRATAP
         AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
         S/O ROHINI ALIAS MOHINI
         R/AT G-2, TATA HOUSING
         CENTRE, LULLUBHAI PARK ROAD
         ANDERI WEST, BOMBAY 400058.
    
    367. PRASHANTH ALIAS PRAKASH
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         S/O ROHINI ALIAS MOHINI
         R/AT G-2, TATA HOUSING
         CENTRE, LULLUBHAI PARK ROAD
         ANDERI WEST, BOMBAY 400058.
    
    368. MALLIKA
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         S/O ROHINI ALIAS MOHINI
         R/AT G-2, TATA HOUSING
         CENTRE, LULLUBHAI PARK ROAD
         ANDERI WEST, BOMBAY 400058.
    
    369. CHANDRAKANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         S/O ROHINI ALIAS MOHINI
         R/AT G-2, TATA HOUSING
         CENTRE, LULLUBHAI PARK ROAD
         ANDERI WEST, BOMBAY 400058.
    
    370. HEMALATHA KOTIAN
         AGED ABOUT 85 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHANTHI
         R/AT 14-473, SUTASH NAGAR
         CHEMBER, BOMBAY 400071.
                              - 67 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    371. VEDAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHANTHI
         R/AT ROOM NO.158,
         JORHABAGA, ASSLFA
         PIPE LINE, GHATKOPPER
         BOMBAY 400084.
    
    372. VIDYULLATHA
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHANTHI
         R/AT. PRAMILA, PATEL CHAL SQUATRS
         COLONY ROAD, MEGHWADI
         JOGEHSWARI EAST, BOMBAY 400060.
    
    373. DEVARAJ AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS
         S/O LATE SHANTHI
         R/AT ROOM NO.2, AMARCHAND
         CO-OP HOUSING SOCIETY
         OPP. MAHALAXMI COLONY
         CEASERS ROAD, AMBOLI VILLAGE
         ANDERI WEST, BOMBAY-400058.
    
    374. PARAMESHA
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         S/O HEMALATHA KOTIAN
         R/AT 14-473, SUTHASH NAGAR
         CHEMBER, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    375. NANDISH
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         S/O HEMALATHA KOTIAN
         R/AT 14-473, SUTHASH NAGAR
         CHEMBER, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    376. JESHWANTHI ALIAS YASHAVANTHI
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         S/O HEMALATHA KOTIAN
         R/AT 14-473, SUTHASH NAGAR
         CHEMBER, BOMBAY 400071.
                              - 68 -
                                         NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    377. KUNAL
         AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
         S/O HEMALATHA KOTIAN
         R/AT 14-473, SUTHASH NAGAR
         CHEMBER, BOMBAY 400071.
    
    378. MAHESH
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         S/O VEDAVATHI
         R/AT ROOM NO.158, JORHABAGH
         ASSLFA, PIPE LINE, GHATKOPPER
         BOMBAY-400084.
    
    379. SHAILAJA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O VEDAVATHI
         R/AT ROOM NO.158, JORHABAGH
         ASSLFA, PIPE LINE, GHATKOPPER
         BOMBAY-400084.
    
    380. NIRANJAN
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
         S/O VEDAVATHI
         R/AT ROOM NO.158, JORHABAGH
         ASSLFA, PIPE LINE, GHATKOPPER
         BOMBAY-400084.
    
    381. CHANDANI
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O VIDYULLATHA
         R/AT. PRAMILA, PATEL CHAL
         SQUATRS, COLONY ROAD
         MEGHWADI, JOGESHWARI EAST
         BOMBAY-400060.
    
    382. LAVANYA
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
         D/O VIDYULLATHA
         R/AT. PRAMILA, PATEL CHAL
         SQUATRS, COLONY ROAD
                                - 69 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         MEGHWADI, JOGESHWARI EAST
         BOMBAY-400060.
    
    383. BHARATH
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O VIDYULLATHA
         R/AT. PRAMILA, PATEL CHAL
         SQUATRS, COLONY ROAD
         MEGHWADI, JOGESHWARI EAST
         BOMBAY-400060.
    384. YOGENDRA
         AGED ABOUT 83 YEARS
         S/O YAMUNA
         R/AT NO.585, 'A' TYPE
         K.G.F. KOLAR-563113.
    
    385. SHIVAPPA
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         S/O LATE JANAMMA
         OCC:CARPENTER
         R/AT. DOOR NO.137-2
         MALANDEVAPET, COORG
         MADIKERI-400060.
    
    386. SHODANPRASAD
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         S/O SUMATHI
         R/AT C/O. GARDIAN, ROYAL
         EXCHANGE INSURANCE
         P.B.NO.5899, RUVI
         MUSCANT-SULTANATE OF OMAN.
    
    387. VENKAPPA
         AGED ABOUT 100 YEARS
         S/O LATE LAXMI
         R/AT. BORICHAL HOUSE BAIWADI
         VOKALA CHURCH (SOUTH)
         BOMBAY-400060.
    
    388. SOWMINI
         AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
                             - 70 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         D/O LATE LEELAVATHI
         R/AT. DOOR NO.175
         OPP. VAKKALIGA HOSTEL
         B.M. ROAD, HASSAN-573201.
    
    389. GUNAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS
         D/O LATE LEELAVATHI
         R/AT. DOOR NO.175
         OPP. VAKKALIGA HOSTEL
         B.M. ROAD, HASSAN-573201.
    
    390. ASHA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O SOWMINI
         R/AT. DOOR NO.175
         OPP. VAKKALIGA HOSTEL
         B.M. ROAD, HASSAN-573201.
    
    391. PRAVEN RAJ
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O SOWMINI
         R/AT. DOOR NO.175
         OPP. VAKKALIGA HOSTEL
         B.M. ROAD, HASSAN-573201.
    
    392. VARADARAJ
         AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
         S/O SOWMINI
         R/AT. DOOR NO.175
         OPP. VAKKALIGA HOSTEL
         B.M. ROAD, HASSAN-573201.
    
    393. VASUKUMARI
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         D/O MAHALAXMI
         R/AT. C/O. BHASKAR SANIL
         DOOR NO.55(2), NEW HOUSE
         NMC 5TH CROSS, OLD TOWN LEFT
         BADRAVATHI-577303.
                                - 71 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    394. RENUKA
         AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
         D/O VASUKUMARI
         R/AT. C/O. BHASKAR SANIL
         DOOR NO.55(2), NEW HOUSE
         NMC 5TH CROSS, OLD TOWN LEFT
         BADRAVATHI-577303.
    
    395. G.V. JAIRAJ
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. C/O. MAJOR, J.G. BALA
         T-179-1, SHAHIBAG OFFICERS
         ENCLAVE NEAR SHAHIBAG TALL NAKA
         AHMEDBAD-380008.
    
    396. JEEVARATHAN
         AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
         S/O SUSHEELA
         R/AT. C/O. SYNDICATE BANK, JAL PALACE
         T-179-1, SHAHIBAG OFFICERS
         ENCLAVE NEAR SHAHIBAG TALL NAKA
         AHMEDBAD-380008.
    
    397. SAROJINI
         AGED ABOUT 96 YEARS
         D/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT. SHANTHI BUILDING
         FLAT NO.15, CHEDDA NAGAR
         CHEMBUR, BOMBAY-400089.
    
    398. SUMATHI
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         D/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT. ASHWINI NIVAS, 1ST FLOOR
         BLOCK NO.3, M-PHULA ROAD
         DOMBIWILL WEST, THANE-421202.
    
    399. SABITHA
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         D/O LATE RAMANI
                                - 72 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. C/O. JAYANTHA & CO-6
         DHANALAXMI REFLE RANGES
         GHATKOPER, BOMBAY-400086.
    
    400. HARINAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 79 YEARS
         D/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT 8/225, SHASHTRI NAGAR
         GOREGON WEST, BOMBAY-400062.
    
    401. JAYANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS
         D/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT. ARUNODAYA, FLAT NO.5
         ODHAR NAGAR, BORIVILI (EAST)
         BOMBAY-400066.
    
    402. RAVIKALA
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         D/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT FLAT NO.5, 2ND FLOOR
         DARSHAN PARLE (C), KALYANINAGAR
         YARWADA, POONA-411014.
    
    403. MOHAN
         AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
         S/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT SHANTHI BUILDING
         FLAT NO.15, CHEDDA NAGAR
         CHEMBUR, BOMBAY-400089.
    
    404. SATHISH
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         S/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT SHANTHI BUILDING
         FLAT NO.15, CHEDDA NAGAR
         CHEMBUR, BOMBAY-400089.
    
    405. ARAVINDA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O LATE RAMANI
                                - 73 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT SHANTHI BUILDING
         FLAT NO.15, CHEDDA NAGAR
         CHEMBUR, BOMBAY-400089.
    
    406. ANUSHA
         AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
         D/O SHOBITHA
         R/AT C/O. JAYANTHA & CO-6
         DHANALAXMI REFLE RANGES
         GHATKOPER, BOMBAY-400086.
    
    407. BABY
         AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
         D/O ANUSHA
         R/AT C/O. JAYANTHA & CO-6
         DHANALAXMI REFLE RANGES
         GHATKOPER, BOMBAY-400086.
    
    408. SUSHMA
         AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
         D/O SHOBITHA
         R/AT C/O. JAYANTHA & CO-6
         DHANALAXMI REFLE RANGES
         GHATKOPER, BOMBAY-400086.
    
    409. KEERTHI
         AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
         D/O SHOBITHA
         R/AT C/O. JAYANTHA & CO-6
         DHANALAXMI REFLE RANGES
         GHATKOPER, BOMBAY-400086.
    
    410. LAVANYA
         AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
         D/O SUMATHI
         R/AT. ASHWINI NIVAS, 1ST FLOOR
         BLOCK NO.3, M-PHULA ROAD
         DOMBIWILL-WEST, THANE-421202.
    
    411. MARIDULA
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
                               - 74 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         S/O SUMATHI
         R/AT 1/9TH , JUHU, VISAL
         J.V.P.D., SCHEME, 5TH FLOOR
         JUHU, BOMBAY-400049.
    
    412. ANIL
         AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
         S/O MARIDULA
         R/AT. ASHWINI NIVAS, 1ST FLOOR
         BLOCK NO.3, M-PHULA ROAD
         DOMBIWILL-WEST, THANE-421202.
    
    413. SUNIL
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         S/O MARIDULA
         R/AT. ASHWINI NIVAS, 1ST FLOOR
         BLOCK NO.3, M-PHULA ROAD
         DOMBIWILL-WEST, THANE-421202.
    
    414. PUNITH
         AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
         S/O LAVANYA
         R/AT. ASHWINI NIVAS, 1ST FLOOR
         BLOCK NO.3, M-PHULA ROAD
         DOMBIWILL-WEST, THANE-421202.
    
    415. PRIYA
         AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
         S/O LAVANYA
         R/AT. ASHWINI NIVAS, 1ST FLOOR
         BLOCK NO.3, M-PHULA ROAD
         DOMBIWILL-WEST, THANE-421202.
    
    416. PRABHAKARA
         AGED ABOUT 88 YEARS
         S/O LATE RAMANI
         R/AT A-20, ROOPE-POOJA CO-OP
         HOUSING SOCIETY, 5TH FLOOR
         BEHIND ST. MARY'S HIGH SCHOOL
         NAHUR, MULAND, BOMBAY-400080.
                               - 75 -
                                       NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    417. NEVADITA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O HARINAKSHI
         R/AT 8/255, SHASHTRI NAGAR
         GOREGON WEST
         BOMBAY-400062.
    
    418. ARCHANA
         AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
         D/O HARINAKSHI
         R/AT 8/255, SHASHTRI NAGAR
         GOREGON WEST
         BOMBAY-400062.
    
    419. THARUN
         AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
         S/O RAVIKALA
         R/AT. FLAT NO.5, II FLLOR
         DARSHAN PARLE (C)
         KALYANINAGAR, YARWADA
         POONA-411014.
    
    420. NIHIL
         AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
         S/O RAVIKALA
         R/AT FLAT NO.5, II FLOOR
         DARSHAN PARLE (C), KALYANINAGAR
         YARWADA, POONA-411014.
    
    421. NAGESH
         AGED ABOUT 89 YEARS
         S/O GANGAMMA
         R/AT. 106/8, DEFENCE CIVIL QUARTERS
         KELINA, VIDYANAGAR
         BOMBAY-400098.
    
    422. VASANTHA
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         S/O GANGAMMA
         R/AT 142/4250, KANNAMVARANAGAR
         VIKROLI, BOMBAY-400083.
                                - 76 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    
    423. GEETHA
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O ROHINI
         R/AT NO.504, VRINDAVAN 2A
         QUARRY ROAD, RAHIJA TOWNSHIP
         MALAD (EAST), BOMBAY-400097.
    
    424. RAJITHA
         AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
         D/O ROHINI
         R/AT. C/O. AGRICULTURAL FINANCE
         CORPORATION LTD., DHANRAJ MAHAL
         CHATRAPATHI SHIVAJI MAHARAJ
         MARG, BOMBAY-400039.
    
    425. NAMITHA
         AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
         D/O ROHINI
         R/AT #16 NAND SUKHSHANTHI M-FULE
         ROAD, BOMBIVIL (WEST)
         THANA-421202.
    
    426. POORNIMA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O ROHINI
         R/AT. C/O. AGRICULTURAL FINANCE
         CORPORATION LTD., DHANRAJ MAHAL
         CHATRAPATHI SHIVAJI MAHARAJ
         MARG, BOMBAY-400039.
    
    427. YATHIS
         AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
         D/O ROHINI
         R/AT NO.504, VRINDAVAN 2A
         QUARRY ROAD RAHIJA TOWNSHIP
         MALAD (EAST), BOMBAY-400097.
    
    428. NATHASHA
         AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS
         D/O RAJITHA
                               - 77 -
                                         NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. C/O. AGRICULTURAL FINANCE
         CORPORATION LTD., DHANRAJ MAHAL
         CHATRAPATHI SHIVAJI MAHARAJ
         MARG, BOMBAY-400039.
    
    429. AKSHAYA
         AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
         S/O NAMITHA
         R/AT #16, NAND SUKHSHANTHI
         M-FUEL ROAD, BOMBIVIL (WEST)
         THANA - 421202.
    
    430. SUNDARA
         AGED ABOUT 106 YEARS
         S/O BAGI
         R/AT. B-9, FLAT NO.6, MEERA NAGAR
         KORAGON PARK, POONA-411004.
    
    431. K.V. AMIN ALIAS VISHWANTH
         AGED ABOUT 84 YEARS
         S/O LATE BHAVANI
         R/AT 35-1029, PANT NAGAR
         GHATKOPR, BOMBAY-400025.
    
    432. RAGHAVA AMIN
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         S/O LATE BHAVANI
         R/AT C/O. P.B. NO.10263
         EXPRESS PRINTING PRESS, SERVICE
         DUBAI UNITED ARAB EMIRATES.
    
    433. VASANTH KUMAR
         AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
         D/O SUNDARI
         R/AT. DOOR NO.401, 'B' SECTOR
         II KUDUREMUKH-577142.
    
    434. SUHASINI S. ANCHAN
         AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
         D/O SUNDARI
         R/AT 1-16, DIVISION NO.1
                              - 78 -
                                      NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                        R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         ANDERI (WEST), J.P. NAGAR
         BOMBAY-400058.
    
    435. PALLAVI
         AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
         D/O SUHASINI S. ANCHAN
         R/AT. 1-16, DIVISION NO.1
         ANDERI (WEST), J.P. NAGAR
         BOMBAY-400058.
    
    436. SURAJ
         AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
         D/O SUHASINI S. ANCHAN
         R/AT 1-16, DIVISION NO.1 ANDERI (WEST)
         J.P. NAGAR, BOMBAY-400058.
    
    437. POOVAMMA
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         WIDOW, LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    438. PUSHPAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS
         D/O LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    439. UMESH
         AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
         S/O LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
                             - 79 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    440. MANOHARA
         AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
         S/O LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    441. CHANDRASHEKARA
         AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
         D/O LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    442. UMAVATHY
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         D/O LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    443. HARISH
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    444. BHAVANISHANKARA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O LATE GOPAL
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
                             - 80 -
                                     NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                      R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    445. KOOSAMMA
         AGED ABOUT 93 YEARS
         WIDOW, LATE MADAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    446. JAGANATH
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O LATE MADHAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    447. CHANDRAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS
         D/O LATE MADHAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    448. DEVAPPA
         AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
         S/O LATE MADHAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    449. UPENDRA
         AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
         D/O LATE MADHAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
                                - 81 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    450. VIDYAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         D/O LATE MADHAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    451. VIJAYA
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O LATE MADHAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    452. BABITHAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
         D/O LATE MADHAVA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-90, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    453. BHASHAVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
         D/O KOOSAMMA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-91, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    454. LOHITHAKSHI
         AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
         D/O KOOSAMMA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-91, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    455. LAXMI
         AGED ABOUT 87 YEARS
                                - 82 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         WIDOW LATE SHIVAPPA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2087, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    456. MOHAN
         AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
         S/O LATE SHIVAPPA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2087, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    
    457. SHALINI
         AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHIVAPPA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2087, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    458. VANITHA
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         D/O LATE SHIVAPPA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2087, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    459. SACHINDANAND
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         S/O LATE SHIVAPPA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2087, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    460. MAMATHA
         AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
                                - 83 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         S/O LATE SHIVAPPA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2087, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    461. SABITHA
         AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
         D/O LAXMI
         R/AT DOOR NO 2087, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    
    462. YAMUNA
         AGED ABOUT 92 YEARS
         WIDOW LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-87, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    463. RAVINDRA
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         S/O LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-87, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    464. THILOTHAMA
         AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
         S/O LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-81, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    465. RANJINI
         AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
                                - 84 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         S/O LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-81, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    466. HARINI
         AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
         D/O LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-81, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    
    467. KESHAVA
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         S/O LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-81, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    468. ROHITHAKSHA
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         S/O LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-81, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    469. UDAYA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         S/O LATE SUNDARA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-81, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    470. JAYASHREE
         AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
                                - 85 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         S/O YAMUNA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-81, MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    471. LAXMI
         AGED ABOUT 86 YEARS
         WIDOW LATE VENKANNA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-88(A), MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    
    472. BHARATHA
         AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
         S/O LATE VENKANNA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-88(A), MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    473. BHANUMATHI
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         D/O LATE VENKANNA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-88(A), MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    474. DEVADAS
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O LATE VENKANNA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-88(A), MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    475. SUREKHA
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
                                - 86 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         D/O LATE VENKANNA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-88(A), MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    476. MALLIKA
         AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
         D/O LATE VENKANNA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-88(A), MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    
    477. GOPALA
         AGED ABOUT 104 YEARS
         S/O LATE SANKAMMA
         R/AT DOOR NO 2-88(1), MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, MAROLI VILLAGE
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    478. RAMADAS
         AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
         S/O PARVATHY
         R/AT MAROLI
         DODDAMANE, (ANCHANNA MANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE, POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 575005.
    
    479. GIRIJA
         AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS
         D/O JANAMMA
         R/AT NAGAPPA COMPOUND, JEPPU
         KANKANADY POST
         MANGALORE-575002.
    
    480. PARVATHI
         AGED ABOUT 91 YEARS
         D/O MANAPPA
                              - 87 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                         R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
         R/AT. UMIKAN, SARIPALLA
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE-575005.
    
    481. SHOBHA
         AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
         D/O PARVATHI
         R/AT. UMIKAN, SARIPALLA
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE-575005.
    
    482. SHASHIKALA
         AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
         D/O PARVATHI
         R/AT. UMIKAN, SARIPALLA
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE-575005.
    
    483. ARASAPPA
         AGED ABOUT 107 YEARS
         S/O SESU
         R/AT DOOR NO.2-88(A)
         MAROLI (ANCHANAMANE)
         MAROLI VILLAGE
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE 57005.
    
    484. ANANDA
         AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS
         S/O SHARADA
         R/AT. NEAR B.M. TILE FACTORY
         MAROLI KEMBR
         MANGALORE-575005.
    
    485. HARISCHANDRA
         AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
         S/O SHARADA ACHANNA
         R/AT. DODDAMEN, MAROLI
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE-575005.
                                - 88 -
                                        NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
                                          R.F.A. No.1968/2024
    
    
    HC-KAR
    
    
    
    486. SHESHAPPA
         AGED ABOUT 106 YEARS
         S/O POOVAPPA
         R/AT. ACHANNAMANE, MAROLI
         POST KULASHEKAR
         MANGALORE-575005.
                                              ...RESPONDENTS
                               ---
    
         THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING
    TO CALL FOR RECORDS IN O.S.NO.87/1991 ON THE FILE OF
    THE II ADDL. C.J. (SR.DN.) & CJM MANGALORE D.K. SET
    ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 31.07.2003 IN
    O.S.NO.87/1991 ON THE FILE OF THE II ADDL. C.J. (SR.DN.) &
    CJM MANGALORE, D.K. & ETC.
    
         THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
    25.02.2026,  COMING   ON   FOR  PRONOUNCEMENT     OF
    JUDGMENT, THIS DAY VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL J., DELIVERED
    THE FOLLOWING:
    
    
    CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
           and
           HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL
    
                         CAV JUDGMENT
    

    (PER: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL)

    This appeal is filed under Section 96 of the Code of

    SPONSORED

    Civil Procedure, 1908, challenging the judgment and

    decree dated 31.07.2003 passed in O.S.No.87/1991 by

    the Court of the II Additional Civil Judge (Sr. Dn.) and

    CJM, Mangalore, D.K.District.

    – 89 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    2. One Chennamma @ Parvathi and others have

    filed a suit for partition of the suit schedule property by

    metes and bounds and for delivery of their shares of the

    suit schedule property. The said suit came to be decreed

    with costs, plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 to 94 and

    defendant Nos.135 to 144 were held entitled to the share

    as mentioned in the judgment and the other defendants

    were also held entitled to the share as mentioned. The

    appellant claiming to be one of the legal heirs of

    Smt.Kochu, has filed this appeal stating that she was not

    arrayed as a party to the suit and she has a right and

    interest over the suit schedule property. The appeal is

    filed along with an application seeking condonation of

    delay of 7039 days.

    3. The learned counsel for the appellant reiterates

    the grounds urged in the appeal and submits that the

    appellant is the grand daughter of Smt.Kochu and without

    making her as a party to the suit, the suit was decreed.

    – 90 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    Hence, she is challenging the judgment and decree dated

    31.07.2003 as she was not having knowledge about the

    same. Hence, he seeks to condone the delay and consider

    the appeal on merits.

    4. We have heard the learned counsel for the

    appellant and meticulously perused the affidavit

    accompanying the application for condonation of delay and

    the other material available on record.

    5. The pleading in the appeal does not indicate as

    to how the appellant is aggrieved by the judgment and

    decree under challenge. The appellant claims to be the

    grand daughter of one Smt.Kochu. However, the

    memorandum of appeal is silent with regard to Smt.Kochu

    being a plaintiff or defendant in the suit. The statement of

    facts or the grounds urged in the appeal do not indicate

    the right of the appellant to file this appeal. Be that as it

    may, the present appeal is filed with a delay of 7039 days

    which is nearly 20 years from the date of judgment and

    – 91 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    decree. The affidavit accompanying the application

    seeking for condonation of delay indicates that the

    appellant was not a party before the Trial Court in

    O.S.No.87/1991, the appellant could not take steps to file

    the above appeal due to the fact that she was minor and

    not aware about the judgment and decree, had financial

    difficulties, she could not approach the advocate to file an

    appeal and only after mobilizing the funds, she preferred

    an appeal and hence, the delay is unintentional and

    beyond her control and she has a good case on merits.

    The aforesaid cause shown in paragraphs 2 and 3 of the

    affidavit cannot be termed as sufficient cause to condone

    the delay of 7039 days in preferring the appeal.

    6. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the following

    cases has laid down the law with regard to consideration

    of the application for condonation of delay. In the

    judgment in BASAWARAJ AND ANOTHER Vs. SPECIAL

    – 92 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER1, the Hon’ble Supreme

    Court in paragraph Nos.11 to 15 has held as under:

    “11. The expression “sufficient cause” should be
    given a liberal interpretation to ensure that
    substantial justice is done, but only so long as
    negligence, inaction or lack of bona fides
    cannot be imputed to the party concerned,
    whether or not sufficient cause has been furnished,
    can be decided on the facts of a particular case and
    no straitjacket formula is possible. (Vide Madanlal v.
    Shyamlal
    [(2002) 1 SCC 535 : AIR 2002 SC 100]
    and Ram Nath Sao v. Gobardhan Sao
    [(2002) 3 SCC
    195 : AIR 2002 SC 1201] .)

    12. It is a settled legal proposition that law of
    limitation may harshly affect a particular party
    but it has to be applied with all its rigour when
    the statute so prescribes. The court has no
    power to extend the period of limitation on
    equitable grounds. “A result flowing from a
    statutory provision is never an evil. A court has no
    power to ignore that provision to relieve what it
    considers a distress resulting from its operation.” The
    statutory provision may cause hardship or
    inconvenience to a particular party but the court has

    1
    (2013) 14 SCC 81

    – 93 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    no choice but to enforce it giving full effect to the
    same. The legal maxim dura lex sed lex which means
    “the law is hard but it is the law”, stands attracted in
    such a situation. It has consistently been held that,
    “inconvenience is not” a decisive factor to be
    considered while interpreting a statute.

    13. The statute of limitation is founded on public
    policy, its aim being to secure peace in the
    community, to suppress fraud and perjury, to
    quicken diligence and to prevent oppression. It seeks
    to bury all acts of the past which have not been
    agitated unexplainably and have from lapse of time
    become stale. According to Halsbury’s Laws of
    England, Vol. 28, p. 266:

    “605. Policy of the Limitation Acts.–The courts
    have expressed at least three differing reasons
    supporting the existence of statutes of
    limitations namely, (1) that long dormant
    claims have more of cruelty than justice in
    them, (2) that a defendant might have lost the
    evidence to disprove a stale claim, and (3) that
    persons with good causes of actions should
    pursue them with reasonable diligence.”

    An unlimited limitation would lead to a sense of
    insecurity and uncertainty, and therefore,
    limitation prevents disturbance or deprivation
    of what may have been acquired in equity and
    justice by long enjoyment or what may have
    been lost by a party’s own inaction, negligence
    or laches. (See Popat and Kotecha Property v.
    SBI Staff Assn.
    [(2005) 7 SCC 510] , Rajender
    Singh v. Santa Singh
    [(1973) 2 SCC 705 : AIR
    1973 SC 2537] and Pundlik Jalam Patil v.
    Jalgaon Medium Project
    [(2008) 17 SCC 448 :

    (2009) 5 SCC (Civ) 907] .)

    – 94 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    14. In P. Ramachandra Rao v. State of Karnataka
    [(2002) 4 SCC 578 : 2002 SCC (Cri) 830 : AIR 2002
    SC 1856] this Court held that judicially engrafting
    principles of limitation amounts to legislating and
    would fly in the face of law laid down by the
    Constitution Bench in Abdul Rehman Antulay v. R.S.
    Nayak
    [(1992) 1 SCC 225 : 1992 SCC (Cri) 93 : AIR
    1992 SC 1701] .

    15. The law on the issue can be summarised to the
    effect that where a case has been presented in the
    court beyond limitation, the applicant has to explain
    the court as to what was the “sufficient cause”

    which means an adequate and enough reason
    which prevented him to approach the court
    within limitation. In case a party is found to be
    negligent, or for want of bona fide on his part
    in the facts and circumstances of the case, or
    found to have not acted diligently or remained
    inactive, there cannot be a justified ground to
    condone the delay. No court could be justified in
    condoning such an inordinate delay by imposing any
    condition whatsoever. The application is to be
    decided only within the parameters laid down by this
    Court in regard to the condonation of delay. In case
    there was no sufficient cause to prevent a litigant to
    approach the court on time condoning the delay

    – 95 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    without any justification, putting any condition
    whatsoever, amounts to passing an order in violation
    of the statutory provisions and it tantamounts to
    showing utter disregard to the legislature.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    7. In the case of SHEO RAJ SINGH Vs. UNION

    OF INDIA AND OTHERS2, the Hon’ble Supreme Court

    has held in paragraph Nos.30 to 36 as under:

    “30. Considering the aforementioned decisions,
    there cannot be any quarrel that this Court has
    stepped in to ensure that substantive rights of
    private parties and the State are not defeated at the
    threshold simply due to technical considerations of
    delay. However, these decisions notwithstanding, we
    reiterate that condonation of delay being a
    discretionary power available to courts, exercise of
    discretion must necessarily depend upon the
    sufficiency of the cause shown and the degree of
    acceptability of the explanation, the length of delay
    being immaterial.

    31. Sometimes, due to want of sufficient cause being
    shown or an acceptable explanation being proffered,
    delay of the shortest range may not be condoned
    whereas, in certain other cases, delay of long periods
    2
    (2023) 10 SCC 531

    – 96 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    can be condoned if the explanation is satisfactory
    and acceptable. Of course, the courts must
    distinguish between an “explanation” and an
    “excuse”. An “explanation” is designed to give
    someone all of the facts and lay out the cause for
    something. It helps clarify the circumstances of a
    particular event and allows the person to point out
    that something that has happened is not his fault, if
    it is really not his fault. Care must, however, be
    taken to distinguish an “explanation” from an
    “excuse”. Although people tend to see “explanation”
    and “excuse” as the same thing and struggle to find
    out the difference between the two, there is a
    distinction which, though fine, is real.

    32. An “excuse” is often offered by a person to deny
    responsibility and consequences when under attack.
    It is sort of a defensive action. Calling something as
    just an “excuse” would imply that the explanation
    proffered is believed not to be true. Thus said, there
    is no formula that caters to all situations and,
    therefore, each case for condonation of delay based
    on existence or absence of sufficient cause has to be
    decided on its own facts. At this stage, we cannot
    but lament that it is only excuses, and not
    explanations, that are more often accepted for
    condonation of long delays to safeguard public
    interest from those hidden forces whose sole agenda

    – 97 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    is to ensure that a meritorious claim does not reach
    the higher courts for adjudication.

    33. Be that as it may, it is important to bear in mind
    that we are not hearing an application for
    condonation of delay but sitting in appeal over a
    discretionary order of the High Court granting the
    prayer for condonation of delay. In the case of the
    former, whether to condone or not would be the only
    question whereas in the latter, whether there has
    been proper exercise of discretion in favour of grant
    of the prayer for condonation would be the question.
    Law is fairly well-settled that “a court of appeal
    should not ordinarily interfere with the discretion
    exercised by the courts below”. If any authority is
    required, we can profitably refer to the decision in
    Manjunath Anandappa v. Tammanasa [Manjunath
    Anandappa v. Tammanasa, (2003) 10 SCC 390] ,
    which in turn relied on the decision in Gujarat Steel
    Tubes Ltd. v. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sabha
    [Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd.
    v. Gujarat Steel Tubes
    Mazdoor Sabha, (1980) 2 SCC 593 : 1980 SCC (L&S)
    197] where it has been held that:

    “an appellate power interferes not when the
    order appealed is not right but only when it is
    clearly wrong”.

    34. The order under challenge in this appeal is dated
    21-12-2011 [Union of India v. Sheo Raj, 2011 SCC
    OnLine Del 5511] . It was rendered at a point of time

    – 98 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    when the decisions in Katiji [Collector (LA) v. Katiji,
    (1987) 2 SCC 107] , Ramegowda [G. Ramegowda v.
    LAO, (1988) 2 SCC 142] , Chandra Mani [State of
    Haryana v. Chandra Mani
    , (1996) 3 SCC 132] , K.V.
    Ayisumma [Tehsildar (LA) v. K.V. Ayisumma
    , (1996)
    10 SCC 634] and Lipok AO [State of Nagaland v.
    Lipok Ao
    , (2005) 3 SCC 752 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 906]
    were holding the field. It is not that the said
    decisions do not hold the field now, having been
    overruled by any subsequent decision. Although
    there have been some decisions in the recent past
    [State of M.P. v. Bherulal [State of M.P. v. Bherulal,
    (2020) 10 SCC 654 : (2021) 1 SCC (Civ) 101 :

    (2021) 1 SCC (Cri) 117 : (2021) 1 SCC (L&S) 84] is
    one such decision apart from University of Delhi
    [University of Delhi v. Union of India
    , (2020) 13 SCC
    745] ] which have not accepted governmental
    lethargy, tardiness and indolence in presenting
    appeals within time as sufficient cause for
    condonation of delay, yet, the exercise of discretion
    by the High Court has to be tested on the anvil of the
    liberal and justice oriented approach expounded in
    the aforesaid decisions which have been referred to
    above
    .

    35. We find that the High Court in the present case
    assigned the following reasons in support of its
    order:

    – 99 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    35.1. The law of limitation was founded on public
    policy, and that some lapse on the part of a litigant,
    by itself, would not be sufficient to deny condonation
    of delay as the same could cause miscarriage of
    justice.

    35.2. The expression “sufficient cause” is elastic
    enough for courts to do substantial justice. Further,
    when substantial justice and technical considerations
    are pitted against one another, the former would
    prevail.

    35.3. It is upon the courts to consider the sufficiency
    of cause shown for the delay, and the length of delay
    is not always decisive while exercising discretion in
    such matters if the delay is properly explained.

    Further, the merits of a claim were also to be
    considered when deciding such applications for
    condonation of delay.

    35.4. Further, a distinction should be drawn between
    inordinate unexplained delay and explained delay,
    where in the present case, the first respondent had
    sufficiently explained the delay on account of
    negligence on part of the government functionaries
    and the government counsel on record before the
    Reference Court.

    – 100 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    35.5. The officer responsible for the negligence
    would be liable to suffer and not public interest
    through the State. The High Court felt inclined to
    take a pragmatic view since the negligence therein
    did not border on callousness.

    36. Given these reasons, we do not consider
    discretion to have been exercised by the High Court
    in an arbitrary manner. The order under challenge
    had to be a clearly wrong order so as to be liable for
    interference, which it is not.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    8. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the aforesaid

    judgments has taken note of its earlier judgment in the

    case of KATIJI referred to supra and held that the

    approach of the Courts in condoning the delay should be

    pragmatic when sufficient cause is shown. In the instant

    case, the cause shown by the appellant is not sufficient to

    condone the enormous delay of nearly 20 years.

    9. It would also be useful to refer to the judgment

    of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of PATHAPATI

    SUBBA REDDY Vs. SPECIAL DEPUTY COLLECTOR

    – 101 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    (LA)3, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in

    paragraph Nos.15, 16, 17 and 26 as under:

    “15. It is in the light of the public policy upon which
    law of limitation is based, the object behind the law
    of limitation and the mandatory and the directory
    nature of Section 3 and Section 5 of the Limitation
    Act that we have to examine and strike a balance
    between Section 3 and Section 5 of the Limitation
    Act in the matters of condoning the delay.

    16. Generally, the courts have adopted a very
    liberal approach in construing the phrase ‘sufficient
    cause’ used in Section 5 of the Limitation Act in
    order to condone the delay to enable the courts to
    do substantial justice and to apply law in a
    meaningful manner which subserves the ends of
    justice. In Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag v.
    Katiji2
    , this Court in advocating the liberal approach
    in condoning the delay for ‘sufficient cause’ held
    that ordinarily a litigant does not stand to benefit by
    lodging an appeal late; it is not necessary to explain
    every day’s delay in filing the appeal; and since
    sometimes refusal to condone delay may result in
    throwing out a meritorious matter, it is necessary in
    the interest of justice that cause of substantial

    3
    2024 SCCOnline SC 513

    – 102 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    justice should be allowed to prevail upon technical
    considerations and if the delay is not deliberate, it
    ought to be condoned. Notwithstanding the above,
    howsoever, liberal approach is adopted in condoning
    the delay, existence of ‘sufficient cause’ for not filing
    the appeal in time, is a condition precedent for
    exercising the discretionary power to condone the
    delay. The phrases ‘liberal approach’, ‘justice-
    oriented approach’ and cause for the advancement
    of ‘substantial justice’ cannot be employed to defeat
    the law of limitation so as to allow stale matters or
    as a matter of fact dead matters to be revived and
    re-opened by taking aid of Section 5 of the
    Limitation Act.

    17. It must always be borne in mind that while
    construing ‘sufficient cause’ in deciding application
    under Section 5 of the Act, that on the expiry of the
    period of limitation prescribed for filing an appeal,
    substantive right in favour of a decree-holder
    accrues and this right ought not to be lightly
    disturbed. The decree-holder treats the decree to be
    binding with the lapse of time and may proceed on
    such assumption creating new rights.

    26. On a harmonious consideration of the provisions
    of the law, as aforesaid, and the law laid down by
    this Court, it is evident that:

    – 103 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    (i) Law of limitation is based upon
    public policy that there should be an
    end to litigation by forfeiting the
    right to remedy rather than the right
    itself;

    (ii) A right or the remedy that has
    not been exercised or availed of for a
    long time must come to an end or
    cease to exist after a fixed period of time;

    (iii) The provisions of the Limitation Act
    have to be construed differently, such as
    Section 3 has to be construed in a strict
    sense whereas Section 5 has to be
    construed liberally;

    (iv) In order to advance substantial
    justice, though liberal approach,
    justice-oriented approach or cause of
    substantial justice may be kept in
    mind but the same cannot be used to
    defeat the substantial law of
    limitation contained in Section 3 of
    the Limitation Act;

    (v) Courts are empowered to exercise
    discretion to condone the delay if
    sufficient cause had been explained, but

    – 104 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    that exercise of power is
    discretionary in nature and may not
    be exercised even if sufficient cause
    is established for various factors
    such as, where there is inordinate
    delay, negligence and want of due
    diligence;

    (vi) Merely some persons obtained
    relief in similar matter, it does not
    mean that others are also entitled to
    the same benefit if the court is not
    satisfied with the cause shown for
    the delay in filing the appeal;

    (vii) Merits of the case are not
    required to be considered in
    condoning the delay; and

    (viii) Delay condonation application has
    to be decided on the parameters laid
    down for condoning the delay and
    condoning the delay for the reason that
    the conditions have been imposed,
    tantamounts to disregarding the statutory
    provision.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    – 105 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    10. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid

    judgments has considered its earlier judgments in the case

    of KATIJI and BASAWARAJ AND ANOTHER referred to

    supra and held that the phrases ‘liberal approach’, ‘justice

    oriented approach’ and ’cause for advancement of

    substantial justice’ cannot be employed to defeat the law

    of limitation so as to allow the stale matter to be revived

    and reopened by taking shelter under Section 5 of the

    Limitation Act. Further, it has been held that no Courts

    would be justified in condoning such inordinate delay by

    imposing any condition whatsoever.

    11. Keeping in mind the enunciation of law laid

    down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court referred to supra, we

    are of the considered view that the appellant has failed to

    show sufficient cause to condone the enormous delay of

    7039 days. The averments made in the affidavit

    accompanying the application for condonation of delay are

    extremely vague and do not provide a satisfactory

    explanation to condone such an enormous delay. The

    – 106 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    condonation of enormous delay as sought by the appellant

    is nothing but a revival of the dead right of the appellant.

    Allowing the application would run contrary to the public

    policy and cause great injustice to the respondents. The

    Court is also required to keep in mind the finality of the lis

    between the parties while condoning the delay. If Courts

    start interpreting the word ‘sufficient cause’ in an unduly

    liberal way even without there being any acceptable

    explanation for condoning the enormous delay, it would

    lead to unsettling the rights of the parties which were

    settled by the Trial Court long ago. In the instant case,

    the appellant has failed to show the sufficient cause to

    condone the delay.

    12. For the aforementioned reasons, we are of the

    considered view that the appellant has failed to show the

    sufficient cause to condone the delay of 7039 days in

    preferring the appeal. Hence, we proceed to pass the

    following:

    – 107 –

    NC: 2026:KHC:14002-DB
    R.F.A. No.1968/2024

    HC-KAR

    ORDER

    I.A.No.1/2024 is dismissed. Consequently, the

    appeal and other pending applications are dismissed.

    Sd/-

    (ANU SIVARAMAN)
    JUDGE

    Sd/-

    (VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL)
    JUDGE

    RV
    List No.: 1 Sl No.: 6



    Source link

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here