Porwin Kari Challam vs . State Of Meghalaya & 3 Ors. on 8 April, 2026

    0
    18
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Meghalaya High Court

    Porwin Kari Challam vs . State Of Meghalaya & 3 Ors. on 8 April, 2026

    Author: H. S. Thangkhiew

    Bench: H. S. Thangkhiew

    Serial No. 02-76 & 78-114
    Regular List
    
    
                          HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
                                AT SHILLONG
    
    WP(C) No. 438 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 439 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 445 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 446 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 447 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 448 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 449 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 450 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 451 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 452 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 453 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 454 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 455 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 456 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 457 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 458 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 459 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 460 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 461 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 462 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 463 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 469 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 476 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 477 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 478 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 479 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 480 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 481 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 482 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 483 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 484 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 486 of 2025
    
    
                                   1
     WP(C) No. 487 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 488 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 489 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 490 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 491 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 492 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 493 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 494 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 495 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 496 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 497 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 498 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 499 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 500 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 501 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 503 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 504 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 505 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 506 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 507 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 508 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 509 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 510 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 511 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 512 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 513 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 514 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 515 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 516 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 517 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 518 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 533 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 534 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 537 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 541 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 542 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 544 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 546 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 547 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 552 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 553 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 554 of 2025
    
    
                            2
     WP(C) No. 555 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 556 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 557 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 558 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 559 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 565 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 567 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 568 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 569 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 572 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 573 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 575 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 576 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 577 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 578 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 579 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 587 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 588 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 592 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 593 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 594 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 595 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 596 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 599 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 601 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 624 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 661 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 662 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 665 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 666 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 669 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 677 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 678 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 679 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 680 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 685 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 711 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 3 of 2026
                                      Date of Order: 08.04.2026
    Porwin Kari Challam     Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Kyrmenskhem Khongshei   Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    
    
                            3
     Teibor Nongkynrih             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Arilla N. Marak               Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Rita Rabha                    Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Lepstone K. Sangma            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Aisha R. Marak                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Kitboklang Lyngdoh            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Ritibil Dkhar                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Hamjhan Lapasam               Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Parikhit Cherenga             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Jitesh G. Momin               Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Swapan Hajong                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Luckybirth S. Marak           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Mostafizur Rahman             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Arkini Sumer                  Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Hemsley Jones Nongrem         Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Penchibal G. Momin            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Md. Ershad Hussain            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Sengmatunisha K. Marak        Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Deishisha Rynjah              Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Stanish A. Sangma             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Bringwell Nongspung           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Eric Williamson Nongkynrih    Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Arborlang Wanniang            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Wanphren Pyngrope             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Baldwin Bhabok Mawroh         Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Anthony Kamar                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Christina Ritshong            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Iadalin Kurbah                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
    Mary C.L. Shullai & 37 Ors.   Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
    Thomas Borwan                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Deovalentine Myrchiang        Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Commonsing Nonglamin          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    William Tham                  Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Frankyson R. Nongpiur         Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Estar Ryntathiang             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Pawbor Lyngdoh                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Denimy Marak                  Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Donboklang Lawriniang         Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Heimonlang I. Lyngdoh         Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Iadashisha Mihsil             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Plielynti Nongsiej            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Mandalin Kharbani             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    
    
                                  4
     Magrina Lyngdoh                   Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Hababiang Lyngdoh                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Amelsing Pathaw                   Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Shanbor Jyrwa                     Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Presha M. Sangma                  Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Anju Challam                      Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Clarity S. Sangma                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Ainki Phawa                       Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Raymond Alfred K. Warjri          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Khrawborlang Kharsyntiew          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Terry Andrew Marbaniang           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Bernadine Shailin Ranee           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Jerry William Ranee               Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Markyrshan Law                    Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Calmlywell Lyngdoh A. Mawphlang Vs.     State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Phrangsngi Sungoh                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Melvin Derick Syiemiong           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Olisha Ryntathiang                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Steven H.Lyngdoh & 40 Ors.        Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Adorisha Tariang & 28 Ors.        Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Tyngkai Bashisha Dohling & 3 Ors. Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    James Plielad Lyngdoh & 5 Ors.    Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Jasperfield Lyndem                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Alden Zenith Lyngdoh Nongbri &
    4 Ors.                            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Peter Silrak R. Marak             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Arnold J. Sangma                  Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Chechong Ch. Marak                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Pdianglang Nonghuloo              Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Ritreki Dhar                      Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Gitaline D. Sangma & 110 Ors.     Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Chesterfield Suja & 8 Ors.        Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Widaka Lakiang & 46 Ors.          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Bibisina Lyngdoh Nongrang &
    11 Ors.                           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Max Steven Sohkhlet               Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Sankidawan Lyngdoh & 59 Ors.      Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Richmond Mark Kenneth Sun         Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Richard James Wahlang             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Laribha Marpna & 34 Ors.          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Johnfriday Lyngkhoi & 26 Ors.     Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
    Paialang Khongnoh & 3 Ors.        Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    
    
                                     5
     Wallambiang Rani & Anr.          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Dutiful Lyngdoh Mawlieh          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Aibanrisuk Ryntathiang           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Fullmoon Myrthong & 35 Ors.      Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
    Mary Grace Iawphniaw             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Badahun Jyrwa & 8 Ors.           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Lam Ki Shaphrang Hujon & Anr.    Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Oliver Wandell Lyndem            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Baleisha Kurbah & 14 Ors.        Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Royalda Nongpluh                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Clarence Basaiowmoit             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Khrawkupar Suting                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Ricky Ram Joshi                  Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Heiporpho Kharshandi & 5 Ors.    Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Bandatngen Lapang                Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Fillingstar Kharumlong & Anr.    Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Precioustone Tyngsong            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Ansimeri Kharsyntiew             Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Lapyndap Shullai                 Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Shalba Dhar                      Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Shaphrangbor Mawkhiew            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Mendarland Kharlyngdoh           Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Mawlynnai Dondor Lyngwa Syiem
    & 2 Ors.                         Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Khrawbor Shylla                  Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 4 Ors.
    Bulsingh Dkhar                   Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Fullmanikstar Marngar            Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Sweet Kenneth Kharkrang          Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 3 Ors.
    Chesterfield Suja & 8 Ors.       Vs.   State of Meghalaya & 5 Ors.
    
    Coram:
               Hon'ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
    
    Appearance In:
    WP(C) No. 438 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 439 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 445 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 446 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 447 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 448 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 449 of 2025
    
    
                                     6
     WP(C) No. 450 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 451 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 452 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 453 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 454 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 455 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 456 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 457 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 458 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 459 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 460 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 461 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 462 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 463 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 469 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 476 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 477 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 478 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 479 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 480 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 481 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 482 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 486 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 487 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 488 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 489 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 490 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 491 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 492 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 493 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 494 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 495 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 496 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 497 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 498 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 499 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 500 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 501 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 503 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 504 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 505 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 506 of 2025
    
    
                            7
     WP(C) No. 507 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 508 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 509 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 510 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 511 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 512 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 513 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 514 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 515 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 516 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 517 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 533 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 534 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 537 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 552 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 553 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 554 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 555 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 556 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 557 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 558 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 559 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 565 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 567 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 568 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 569 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 573 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 575 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 576 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 577 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 578 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 579 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 587 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 588 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 624 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 662 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 677 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 678 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 679 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 680 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 685 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 711 of 2025
    
    
                            8
     For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :   Dr. N.Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
                                        Ms. T.Sutnga, Adv.
    
    For the Respondent(s)           :   Mr. A.Kumar, AG with

    Mrs. T.Yangi B, AAG
    Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA.
    Ms. S.Laloo, GA.

    WP(C) No. 3 of 2026

    SPONSORED

    For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Dr. N.Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
    Ms. T.Sutnga, Adv.

    For the Respondent(s) : Mr. A.Kumar, AG with
    Mrs. T.Yangi B, AAG
    Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA.
    Ms. S.Laloo, GA for R 1-5.

    Ms. B.Kharwanlang, Adv. for R 6.

    Appearance in:

    WP(C) No. 483 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 484 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 518 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 541 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 542 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 572 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 592 of 2025

    WP(C) No. 593 0f 2025
    WP(C) No. 594 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 595 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 596 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 599 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 601 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 661 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 665 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 666 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 669 of 2025

    For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S.Pandey, Adv.

    Mr. G.Chettry, Adv.

    9

    For the Respondent(s) : Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
    Mrs. T. Yangi B, AAG
    Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA
    Ms. S.Laloo, GA.

    Appearance in:

    WP(C) No. 544 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 546 of 2025
    WP(C) No. 547 of 2025

    For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Ms. J.T.Sangma, Adv.

    For the Respondent(s) : Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
    Mrs. T. Yangi B, AAG
    Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA.
    Ms. S.Laloo, GA.

    Appearance in:

    WP(C). No. 565 of 2025

    For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. B.Deb, Adv.

    Ms. P.Kharmawshun, Adv.

    For the Respondent(s) : Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
    Mrs. T. Yangi B, AAG
    Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA.
    Ms. S.Laloo, GA.

    It is submitted by learned Advocate General that affidavits have since
    been filed in the following matters:

    (i) WP(C). No. 438 of 2025 (Textile Department).

    (ii) WP(C). No. 478 of 2025 (Water Resource Department).

    (iii) WP(C). No. 565 of 2025 (Agriculture Department).

    (iv) WP(C). No. 587 of 2025 (GAD Department)

    10

    (v) WP(C). No. 596 of 2025 (PHE Department).

    (vi) WP(C). No. 711 of 2025 (AH & Veterinary Department).

    However, he prays for further two weeks’ time to file the affidavit in
    respect of Health Department. Prayer is allowed.

    List this matter on 29-04-2026.
    Rejoinder to be filed to the affidavits that have already been filed by
    the State respondents in the meanwhile.

    Judge

    Meghalaya
    08.04.2026
    “Samantha PS”

    11



    Source link

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here