Har Prasad Sahu vs State Of Chhattisgarh on 28 April, 2026

    0
    54
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Chattisgarh High Court

    Har Prasad Sahu vs State Of Chhattisgarh on 28 April, 2026

                                                         1
    NIRMALA
    RAO
    
    
    
    
                                                                          2026:CGHC:19590
    
    
                                                                                           NAFR
    
                          HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
    
                                             WPS No. 5169 of 2022
    
    
              1 - Har Prasad Sahu S/o Late Shri Goverdhan Sahu Aged About 55 Years Patwari,
              Patwri Cercle No. 12, Village Karanja, Bhilai, Tahsil And District Durg (C.G.)
                                                                              ... Petitioner(s)
    
    
                                                       versus
    
    
              1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Revenue Department Ministry,
              Mahanadi Bhawan, New Raipur P.S. Rakhi (C.G.)
    
    
              2 - Collector Durg (C.G.)
    
    
              3 - Sub Divisional Officer Durg (C.G.)
                                                                             ... Respondent(s)

    For Petitioner : Shri Shashi Kumar Kushwaha,
    Advocate.

    For Respondents/ State : Mr. Anmol Sharma, P.L.

    SPONSORED

    Hon’ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
    Judgment On Board

    28.4.2026

    1) By way of this petition, petitioner has sought following reliefs:-

    “10.1 That, this Hon’ble Court may kindly be
    pleased to quashed punishment of withholding
    of two annual increments of petitioner without
    cumulative effect and quashed order dated
    2

    17-02-2022 of Commissioner Durg Division
    Durg maintaining order dated 26-04-2021 of
    Collector Durg and order dated 05-02-2021 of
    Sub Divisional Officer Durg (C.G.).

    10.3 That cost of litigation and any other relief
    which the Hon’ble Court deems fit may kindly
    also be awarded.”

    2) Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that at the

    relevant time, the petitioner, who was posted as Patwari, Halka

    No.12, Tehsil and District Durg was served with a show-cause

    notice dated 17.12.2020 wherein, it was alleged that he failed to

    complete revenue entries in computer. The petitioner filed a reply

    to the show-cause notice on 19.12.2020 and thereafter, the

    disciplinary authority, vide order dated 5.2.2021, inflicted the

    penalty of stoppage of two increments with noncumulative effect.

    He would submit that the petitioner preferred an appeal before the

    Collector, which was dismissed vide order dated 26.4.2021 and

    thereafter, the second appeal preferred by the petitioner was also

    dismissed by the Commissioner, Durg, vide order dated

    17.2.2022. He would submit that the disciplinary authority failed

    to comply with the procedure contemplated under Rule 16 of the

    Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Classification Control and Appeal)

    Rules, 1966 to inflict minor penalty and therefore, the order

    passed by the disciplinary authority and the subsequent orders

    are bad in law.

    3) On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the State would

    oppose. He would submit that the petitioner, in his reply to show-
    3

    cause notice, admitted that there was a mistake on his part and

    therefore, there was no need to conduct an enquiry. It is also

    contended that as a minor penalty was inflicted, therefore, there

    was no requirement to conduct a full-fledged enquiry.

    4) I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the

    documents placed on record.

    5) A plain reading of the reply of the petitioner shows that the

    petitioner has given explanation in relation to the charges alleged

    against him. The petitioner also denied the allegations and

    requested to drop the enquiry. This is trite that the admission of

    charge must be unconditional, unqualified and unequivocal. In

    the matter of Ghanshyam v. State of M.P. 2013(1) MPWN

    18=2013 (1) MPLJ 144, the High Court of Madhya Pradesh held,

    in paragraphs 8 & 9, as under:

    “8. This is settled in law that unless the admission of
    guilt/charges is specific, unconditional, unqualified and
    unequivocal, enquiry cannot be dispensed with. In the
    present case, the petitioner has put forth his defence
    and made an effort to show that he is not responsible
    for the charges and the payment was made on the
    basis of attendance certified by subordinate employee.
    Thus, it cannot be said that petitioner has admitted the
    charges in totality and without any explanation. In
    (1998)1 SCC 756, General Court-Martial v. Co. Aniltej
    Singh Dhaliwal
    , it is held that an admission can be
    explained by the makers thereof. An admission is not
    conclusive as to the truth of the matter stated therein
    4

    and it is only a piece of evidence, the weight to be
    attached to which must depend upon the
    circumstances under which it is made. In 1961 JLJ
    414-AIR 1961 SC 1070, Jagdish Prasad Saxena v.

    State of Madhya Bharat (now Madhya Pradesh), a
    Constitution Bench of Supreme Court held as under:

    “Held that, as the statements made by the appellant
    did not amount to a clear or unambiguous admission
    of his guilt, failure to hold a formal enquiry constituted
    a serious infirmity in the order of dismissal passed
    against him, as the appellant had no opportunity at all
    of showing cause against the charge framed against
    him.

    Even if the appellant had made some statements
    which amounted to admission, it was open to doubt
    whether he could be removed from service on the
    strength of the said alleged admissions without
    holding a formal enquiry as required by the Rules.”

    9. On the basis of aforesaid test laid down by the
    Supreme Court, if Annexure P-7 is tested it will show
    that petitioner has given explanation against show
    cause notice and there is no unequivocal,
    unconditional, unqualified and specific admission of
    guilt by the petitioner. Thus, in the considered opinion
    of this Court, the respondents have erred in treating
    Annexure P-7 as admission of guilt. Consequently, the
    respondents have committed an error in not
    conducting the enquiry. On the basis of aforesaid
    analysis, Annexures P-1 and P-2 are liable to be set
    aside and 1 do so. Accordingly, Annexures P-1 and P-
    2 are set aside.”

    5

    6) The reply, by no stretch of imagination, amounts to admission

    of charges and, therefore, I am unable to hold that no inquiry was

    required.

    7) The Apex Court in the matter of (O.K. Bhardwaj v. Union of

    India and others, reported in (2001) 9 SCC 180) opined that

    where allegations are factual in nature and the delinquent

    employee has denied the same while filing reply, no punishment

    should be imposed without holding an inquiry. A careful reading of

    Rule 16 of the Rules of 1966 also shows that the Disciplinary

    Authority is required to conduct an inquiry in such matters where

    allegations are factual and delinquent employee has not admitted

    the same. The punishment order shows that reply of the petitioner

    has not been considered at all. Rule 16 of the Rules of 1966

    further mandates that the Disciplinary Authority is bound to assign

    reasons for the conclusion arrived at by him. For these cumulative

    reasons, in my opinion, the decision making process adopted by

    the department is erroneous and runs contrary to the principles of

    natural justice and Rule 16 of the Rules of 1966.

    8) Resultantly, the punishment order dated 5.2.2021 (Annexure-

    P/3), the Appellate Order dated 26.4.2021 (Annexure P-2) and the

    second Appellate Order dated 17.2.2022 (Annexure-P/1) are

    hereby set aside. The petition is allowed to the extent indicated

    above. However, the respondents would be at liberty to initiate a

    fresh enquiry strictly in accordance with law, if so advised.
    6

    9) With the aforesaid observation(s), this petition is allowed.

    Sd/-

    (Rakesh Mohan Pandey)
    JUDGE
    Nimmi

    [ad_1]

    Source link

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here